PG 10 · cols. 45–50
A. Gallandius, Notitia altera de Julio Africano
Editors' preface
Migne Reading Room
PG 10 · cols. 45–50
Editors' preface
<!-- Notes (17) and (18) belong to the preceding piece (Greek with facing Latin, ending at the head of this page); their calls fall above the visible foot. Note (1) belongs to the Notitia altera, which begins on this page in full-width Latin. --> (printed under page 29)
(1) ‹anchor: scribit Eusebius› · call in col 45
Euseb. in Chron. ad ann. 2237.
Eusebius, Chronicle, at the year 2237.
(printed under page 29)
(17) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 46
Alius et antiquior fuit Bardesanes, Babylonius, quem sub Alexandro Severo vixisse (adeoque Africani fuisse aequalem), male affirmat Vossius lib. iv, pag. 483, De hist. Graec. Nam licet Porphyrius iv Περὶ ἀποχῆς illum scripsisse ait aetate πατέρων, illud tamen latius accipiendum est, et Antonini tempora respicit, ut testatur Porphyrius ipse fragmento de Styge, ubi refert narrationem illam de aqua probationis Tantalia Brachmanum, tradidisse τοὺς ἐπὶ τῆς βασιλείας τοῦ Ἀντωνίνου τοῦ ἐξ Ἐμεσῶν εἰς τὴν Συρίαν ἀφικνουμένου, Βαρδησάνη τῷ ἐκ Μεσοποταμίας εἰς λόγους ἀφικνουμένους. Ex hoc loco colligitur quoque, eumdem esse Bardesanem, qui de Indorum philosophis scripsit, teste Porphyrio et Hieron. ii contra Jovinian., et qui dialogum De fato ad Antoninum imper. edidit, de quo infra lib. v. Neque difficilia solutu sunt argumenta Friderici Strunzii in Historia Bardesanis et Bardesanistarum, quibus contendit duos diversos fuisse. Sub Elagabalo Antonino vixisse contendunt Grabe i Spicilegii, pag. 317, et Dodwellus iv, 35, Diss. ad Irenaeum ex Porphyrii loco de Styge. FABRIC.—Fabricio accedit Jac. de Rhoer ad Porphyrium De abstinentia ab esu animalium lib. iv, § 17, pag. 356. Porphyrii illud fragmentum publicarunt primus Andr. Schottus ex cod. Augustini, in Obss. human., pag. 229, et post eum Luc. Holsten., emendatius, inter opuscula Porphyrii Rom. 1630, pag. 148-153, ex cod. Vaticano. Post Holstenium Latine eum vertit Tollius in Fortuitis, cap. 28. Emendatiorem tamen dedit locum cl. Heeren in Joann. Stobaei Eclog. physicar. et ethic. libris ii, part. prima (Gottingae, 1792, 8), pag. 140 sqq. et in notis accurate lateque disserit de Bardisane et Babylonio et Syro, cujus nomen in haeretices historia haud obscurum est. Oppugnat autem Fabricium, et docet a Bardisane Syro plane diversum esse Bardisanem Babylonium, quem sequitur Porphyrius in fragmento citato, Vossiique judicio, illum Babylonium floruisse sub Alexandro Severo, adeoque centum circiter annos a Bardisane Syro abfuisse, subscribit, et statuit, τὸν Ἀντωνῖνον, τὸν ἐξ Ἐμεσῶν, non esse Marcum illum philosophum; sed potius Heliogabalum, Alexandri Severi antecessorem, qui, ex urbe Emesa ortus, cum imperator factus esset, Antonini nomen recepit. Concludit igitur, constitui inde aetatem scriptoris, Bardisanis Babylonii, eamque utique ad Heliogabali et Alexandri tempora cum Vossio rejiciendam esse. HARL.
There was another and older Bardesanes, the Babylonian, whom Vossius (De historicis Graecis, book IV, p. 483) wrongly asserts lived under Alexander Severus (and so was a contemporary of Africanus). For although Porphyry (On Abstinence IV) says that he wrote "in the age of our fathers", that must be taken more broadly, and it looks to the times of Antoninus, as Porphyry himself attests in the fragment on the Styx, where he relates that the story of the Brahmans' water of ordeal, the Tantalian water, was handed down by "those who, in the reign of Antoninus of Emesa, came into Syria and came to converse with Bardesanes of Mesopotamia". From this passage it is also gathered that this is the same Bardesanes who wrote on the philosophers of the Indians, on the testimony of Porphyry and of Jerome (Against Jovinian II), and who published a dialogue On Fate addressed to the emperor Antoninus, of which see below, book V. Nor are the arguments of Friedrich Strunz in his History of Bardesanes and the Bardesanites hard to answer, by which he contends that there were two different men. Grabe (Spicilegium I, p. 317) and Dodwell (Dissertations on Irenaeus IV, 35) contend from Porphyry's passage on the Styx that he lived under Elagabalus Antoninus. FABRICIUS.—Jac. de Rhoer, on Porphyry's On Abstinence from Eating Animals, book IV, § 17, p. 356, sides with Fabricius. That fragment of Porphyry was first published by Andreas Schott from Augustinus's manuscript in his Observationes humanae, p. 229, and after him, more correctly, by Lucas Holstenius among Porphyry's opuscula (Rome 1630), pp. 148–153, from a Vatican manuscript. After Holstenius, Tollius translated it into Latin in his Fortuita, ch. 28. But the distinguished Heeren gave a more correct text of the passage in his Joannes Stobaeus, Eclogae physicae et ethicae, two books, first part (Göttingen, 1792, octavo), pp. 140 ff., and in the notes discusses accurately and at length both Bardesanes the Babylonian and Bardesanes the Syrian, whose name is far from obscure in the history of heresy. He opposes Fabricius, and shows that Bardesanes the Babylonian, whom Porphyry follows in the fragment cited, is quite distinct from Bardesanes the Syrian; he subscribes to Vossius's judgement that the Babylonian flourished under Alexander Severus, and so stood some hundred years apart from Bardesanes the Syrian; and he holds that "Antoninus of Emesa" is not the philosopher Marcus but rather Heliogabalus, Alexander Severus's predecessor, who was born in the city of Emesa and took the name Antoninus when he became emperor. He concludes, therefore, that the date of the writer, Bardesanes the Babylonian, is fixed by this, and that with Vossius it must certainly be put back to the times of Heliogabalus and Alexander. HARLES.
(printed under page 29)
(18) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 46
De Gratiani imper. spiculis semper ferientibus destinata dictum: τὰ Γρατιάνου βέλη φρένας ἔχειν, Cangius ad Zonaram, pag. 42.
Of the emperor Gratian's arrows, which always struck their mark, it was said: "Gratian's darts have minds of their own." Du Cange on Zonaras, p. 42.
(printed under page 29)
<!-- Latin-only text in two columns; the notes run on from the left foot to the right foot. Calls (2)–(17) fall in col 47; call (18) falls in col 48. --> (printed under page 30)
(2) ‹anchor: episcopus Caesariensis› · call in col 47
Euseb. Hist. eccl., lib. vi, cap. 31.
Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, book VI, ch. 31.
(printed under page 30)
(3) ‹anchor: praeterea docet› · call in col 47
Id. in Chron. l. c.
The same, in the Chronicle, at the place cited.
(printed under page 30)
(4) ‹anchor: ex eoque Hieronymus› · call in col 47
Hieron. De vir. illustr. cap. 63.
Jerome, On Illustrious Men, ch. 63.
(printed under page 30)
(5) ‹anchor: plura Scaliger› · call in col 47
Scalig. Animadv. ad Euseb. Chron. pag. 232.
Scaliger, Animadversiones on Eusebius's Chronicle, p. 232.
(printed under page 30)
(6) ‹anchor: ut par erat, addidimus› · call in col 47
Nos vero utramque epistolam inter Origenis Opera retinuimus; adeat lector tomum proxime sequentem. EDIT. PATR.
We, however, have kept both letters among the works of Origen; the reader may consult the next volume. EDITOR OF THE PATROLOGIA.
(printed under page 30)
(7) ‹anchor: Origenianorum editoris› · call in col 47
Vide eumdem tomum. ID.
See the same volume. THE SAME.
(printed under page 30)
(8) ‹anchor: inquit post Eusebium› · call in col 47
Euseb. Hist. eccl. lib. vi, cap. 31.
Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, book VI, ch. 31.
(printed under page 30)
(9) ‹anchor: Eusebium Hieronymus› · call in col 47
Hieron. De vir. illustr., cap. 63.
Jerome, On Illustrious Men, ch. 63.
(printed under page 30)
(10) ‹anchor: Faustum Manichaeum retractans› · call in col 47
Aug. Retract. lib. ii, cap. 7, § 2, Opp. tom. I, pag. 44.
Augustine, Retractations, book II, ch. 7, § 2, Works vol. I, p. 44.
(printed under page 30)
(11) ‹anchor: Meminerunt praeterea Photius› · call in col 47
Phot. Bibl. cod. 34.
Photius, Bibliotheca, codex 34.
(printed under page 30)
(12) ‹anchor: Zacharias Chrysopolitanus› · call in col 47
Zachar. Chrysop. Comment. in Harmon. Ammon. lib. i, cap. 5, Bibl. PP. Lugd. tom. XIX, pag. 751.
Zacharias of Chrysopolis, Commentary on Ammonius's Harmony, book I, ch. 5, Bibliotheca Patrum (Lyons), vol. XIX, p. 751.
(printed under page 30)
(13) ‹anchor: Nicephorus Callisti› · call in col 47
Niceph. Call. Hist. eccl. lib. v, cap. 21.
Nicephorus Callistus, Ecclesiastical History, book V, ch. 21.
(printed under page 30)
(14) ‹anchor: alibi profert› · call in col 47
Id. ibid. lib. i, cap. 11.
The same, ibid., book I, ch. 11.
(printed under page 30)
(15) ‹anchor: ut ait Hieronymus› · call in col 47
Hieron. De vir. illustr., cap. 63.
Jerome, On Illustrious Men, ch. 63.
(printed under page 30)
(16) ‹anchor: inquit Eusebius› · call in col 47
Euseb. Hist. eccl. lib. vi, cap. 31.
Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History, book VI, ch. 31.
(printed under page 30)
(17) ‹anchor: judice Photio› · call in col 47
Phot. Bibl. cod. 34.
Photius, Bibliotheca, codex 34.
(printed under page 30)
(18) ‹anchor: Erant, inquit› · call in col 48
Dodw. Dissert. sing. ad opp. post. Pearson, § 8, pag. 98 seq.
Dodwell, Dissertatio singularis on Pearson's posthumous works, § 8, pp. 98 f.
(printed under page 30)
<!-- Latin-only text in two columns; the notes run on from the left foot to the right foot. Call (19) falls in col 49 above the visible foot; (20) is visible near the foot of col 49; calls (21)–(26) are not visible and, coming after (20), must fall in the upper part of col 50; (27)–(29) are visible in col 50. --> (printed under page 31)
(19) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 49
Syncell., pag. 212.
Syncellus, p. 212.
(printed under page 31)
(20) ‹anchor: esse perhibetur› · call in col 49
Vide Fabric. Bibl. Gr. tom. VI, pag. 57.
See Fabricius, Bibliotheca Graeca, vol. VI, p. 57.
(printed under page 31)
(21) ‹anchor: κατὰ λέξιν οὕτως› · call in col 50
Apud Lambec. Comment. lib. i, pag. 141.
In Lambecius, Commentarii, book I, p. 141.
(printed under page 31)
(22) ‹anchor: Νῦν δ' ἂν› · call in col 50
Edit. ὧν. Et paulo post, τούτοις συντ.
The edition reads ὧν; and a little after, τούτοις συντ[…].
(printed under page 31)
(23) ‹anchor: emendatius exstare› · call in col 50
Euseb. Demonstr. evang. lib. viii, cap. 2, pag. 3.
Eusebius, Demonstration of the Gospel, book VIII, ch. 2, p. 3.
(printed under page 31)
(24) ‹anchor: S. Hieronymum› · call in col 50
Hieron. Comment. in Daniel. ix, 24, Opp. tom. III, pag. 1110 edit. Martian.
Jerome, Commentary on Daniel 9:24, Works vol. III, p. 1110, Martianay's edition.
(printed under page 31)
(25) ‹anchor: quoque Caveum› · call in col 50
Cav. Hist. litt. tom. I, pag. 111.
Cave, Historia literaria, vol. I, p. 111.
(printed under page 31)
(26) ‹anchor: et Fabricium› · call in col 50
Fabric. Bibl. Gr. tom. V, pag. 169.
Fabricius, Bibliotheca Graeca, vol. V, p. 169.
(printed under page 31)
(27) ‹anchor: haec refert› · call in col 50
Lambec. l. c. lib. iii, pag. 39.
Lambecius, at the place cited, book III, p. 39.
(printed under page 31)
(28) ‹anchor: idem Lambecius› · call in col 50
Id. ibid. lib. v, pag. 297.
The same, ibid., book V, p. 297.
(printed under page 31)
(29) ‹anchor: Montfauconio descriptum› · call in col 50
Montf. Coll. Nov. PP. Graec., t. II, p. 105.
Montfaucon, Collectio nova Patrum Graecorum, vol. II, p. 105.
(printed under page 31)