PL 38 · cols. 221–234
Augustine, Sermones 35-45 (Classis I, de Scripturis: de Proverbiis, Ecclesiastico, Isaia)
Sermon XXXVII
Migne Reading Room
PL 38 · cols. 221–234
Sermon XXXVII
(*) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 221 Recognitus est in duobus s. in cl. cb. gr. et in Ulim. Par. Lov.
Revised against two s. manuscripts, against cl., cb., gr., and against Ulim., the Paris edition, the Louvain edition.
(printed under page 117)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 221
Alias, de Diversis 45.
Formerly, de Diversis 45.
(printed under page 117)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 221
Augustino tribuunt hunc sermonem non tantum libri Mss. omnes, quos videre nobis contigit; sed etiam Possidius in Indiculi capite 8, Beda ad Gal. 3, Florus ibidem et ad Rom. 8. Quibus adde, Donati schisma hic capp. 2 et 3 aperte reprehendi, et Augustini ubique inesse ingenium atque doctrinam. Errore itaque manifesto est inter Ambrosii opera excusus; ubi falso insuper titulo, « In die SS. Machabaeorum habitus, » praenotatur. Certe enim non una tantum, sed plures feminae illis quae praelecta fuerant ante sermonem, passionis Actis commemorabantur, ut legitur hic cap. 1; et harum una id cap. 16 refertur dixisse in confessione, « Honorem Caesari quasi Caesari, timorem autem Deo. »
Not only do all the manuscript books that we have happened to see ascribe this sermon to Augustine, but so also do Possidius in chapter 8 of the Indiculus, Bede on Gal. 3, and Florus on the same place and on Rom. 8. Add to these that the schism of Donatus is openly censured here in chapters 2 and 3, and that Augustine's cast of mind and teaching are present throughout. It was therefore by a manifest error that it was printed among the works of Ambrose, where moreover it is headed with the false title, "Delivered on the day of the holy Maccabees." For certainly not one woman only but several were commemorated in those Acts of a passion which had been read out before the sermon, as is read here in chapter 1; and one of them is reported in chapter 16 to have said this in her confession: "Honour to Caesar as to Caesar, but fear to God."
(printed under page 117)
(1) ‹anchor: dici quae latet› · call in col 222
Hoc loco apud Ambrosium additur: Illam enim solus invenit Deus, sicut dixit Apostolus, Cognovit Dominus qui sunt ejus. Et paulo post ad verba, unius uxor est, haec subjiciuntur: Ut scribit Apostolus ad Ephesios dicens, Sacramentum hoc magnum est, etc. Est quoque mater, sicut dictum est, Illa autem quae sursum est Jerusalem, libera est, quae est mater nostra, et multorum filiorum, quia multi filii desertae. Isthaec aliaque ibidem facta sermoni additamenta non reperiuntur in nostris Mss.
At this place in the Ambrose printing there is added: "For God alone found her, as the Apostle said, The Lord knows those who are His." And a little later, at the words unius uxor est, the following is subjoined: "As the Apostle writes to the Ephesians, saying, This is a great mystery, etc. She is also a mother, as it is said, But that Jerusalem which is above is free, which is our mother, and of many children, because many are the children of the desolate one." These and other additions made to the sermon in that place are not found in our manuscripts.
(printed under page 117)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 223
Colbertinus Ms., quantum teneo, quantum tenere debetis.
The Colbert manuscript: quantum teneo, quantum tenere debetis ("as far as I hold, as far as you ought to hold").
(printed under page 118)
(2) ‹anchor: eloquium unde fulget› · call in col 223
In Ms. Sorbonico, unde fulgent. Apud Ambrosium, unde haec mulier fulget.
In the Sorbonne manuscript, unde fulgent. In the Ambrose printing, unde haec mulier fulget ("by which this woman shines").
(printed under page 118)
(3) ‹anchor: se amari voluit› · call in col 223
Corbeiensis Ms.: Ille qui in ea remansit, se ornare voluit.
The Corbie manuscript: Ille qui in ea remansit, se ornare voluit ("He who remained in her wished to adorn himself").
(printed under page 118)
(4) ‹anchor: quia caro valent› · call in col 223
Sic potiores Mss. Editi vero, quia charitate valent.
So the better manuscripts. The printed editions, however: quia charitate valent ("because they are strong in charity").
(printed under page 118)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 224 (numeral as it appears at the foot of the right column)
Editi: Hoc enim et promisit viro ejus. Emendantur hic ad Mss.
The printed editions: Hoc enim et promisit viro ejus ("For this she also promised to her husband"). They are corrected here according to the manuscripts.
(printed under page 118)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 225
Ita Mss. At editi omittunt particulam, sine.
So the manuscripts. But the printed editions omit the particle sine.
(printed under page 119)
(2) ‹anchor: prospicit enim agrum› · call in col 225
Ms. Corbeiensis: In omnibus tribulationibus prospicit agrum. Colbertinus: In omnibus tribulationem patiens, sed non deficiens, prospicit agrum.
The Corbie manuscript: In omnibus tribulationibus prospicit agrum ("In all tribulations she looks ahead to the field"). The Colbert manuscript: In omnibus tribulationem patiens, sed non deficiens, prospicit agrum ("Suffering tribulation in all things, yet not failing, she looks ahead to the field").
(printed under page 119)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 226
Apud Ambrosium et in Sorbonicis Mss., pro agro illo. In Corbeiensi, vel quis ager ille?
In the Ambrose printing and in the Sorbonne manuscripts: pro agro illo ("for that field"). In the Corbie manuscript: vel quis ager ille? ("or what field is that?").
(printed under page 119)
(2) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 226
In Sorbonicis Mss. deest, habentibus; ejusque loco in Germanensi est, levantibus. At in Corbeiensi pro, cor habentibus, etc., legitur sic: Colit agrum illum non respiciens quae videntur, etc.
In the Sorbonne manuscripts habentibus is wanting; and in its place the Saint-Germain manuscript has levantibus. But in the Corbie manuscript, in place of cor habentibus, etc., the reading is: Colit agrum illum non respiciens quae videntur, etc. ("She tills that field, not looking at the things that are seen," etc.).
(printed under page 119)
(3) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 226
Mss. Sorbonici et Germanensis, unde compares agelli.
The Sorbonne manuscripts and the Saint-Germain manuscript: unde compares agelli. [The last word is broken across the line and faint in the scan; the reading is uncertain.]
(printed under page 119)
(4) ‹anchor: conscientia bona› · call in col 226
Ms. Colbertinus, facit conscientiam bonam.
The Colbert manuscript: facit conscientiam bonam ("makes a good conscience").
(printed under page 119)
(5) ‹anchor: amara sunt omnia› · call in col 226
Ms. Corbeiensis: Et quid amarius mala? Mala enim pungit, et cui inest, amara sunt omnia.
The Corbie manuscript: Et quid amarius mala? Mala enim pungit, et cui inest, amara sunt omnia ("And what is more bitter than a bad one? For a bad one stings, and to him in whom it is, all things are bitter").
(printed under page 119)
(1) ‹anchor: quo pervenit› · call in col 227
Apud Ambrosium: Ecce quo perveniunt. In Ms. Colbertino sic legitur, et a flumine unde coepit, usque ad terrae terminos quo pervenit.
In the Ambrose printing: Ecce quo perveniunt ("See how far they reach"). In the Colbert manuscript the reading is: et a flumine unde coepit, usque ad terrae terminos quo pervenit ("and from the river where it began, to the ends of the earth where it has reached").
(printed under page 120)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 228
Mss. aliquot, neat.
Several manuscripts: neat.
(printed under page 120)
(2) ‹anchor: conservis cibaria› · call in col 228
Codex cb., et dividet eum, ne socius sit ministrorum et praepositorum copiarum ejus, qui dant in tempore conservis cibaria. Et paulo infra: Non totum ministrorum, quia.
Codex cb.: et dividet eum, ne socius sit ministrorum et praepositorum copiarum ejus, qui dant in tempore conservis cibaria ("and he will divide him, lest he be a companion of the ministers and overseers of his stores, who give their fellow servants their rations in due season"). And a little below: Non totum ministrorum, quia.
(printed under page 120)
(1) ‹anchor: duplicia sunt pallia› · call in col 229
Ms. Germanensis, sicut scriptum legimus, duplicia sumit pallia. Sic etiam Colbertinus et Corbeiensis, nisi quod hic omittit verbum, sumit; ille ejus loco habet, sunt.
The Saint-Germain manuscript: sicut scriptum legimus, duplicia sumit pallia ("as we read it written, she takes double cloaks"). So also the Colbert and Corbie manuscripts, except that the latter omits the word sumit, and the former has sunt in its place.
(printed under page 121)
(2) ‹anchor: mortuus non est› · call in col 229
Ms. Germanensis, quia ille resurgere potuit, qui mortuus est.
The Saint-Germain manuscript: quia ille resurgere potuit, qui mortuus est ("because he was able to rise again who died").
(printed under page 121)
(3) ‹anchor: colo hujus mulieris› · call in col 229
Apud Ambrosium, et totum veritas, quidquid de tela hujus mulieris procedit.
In the Ambrose printing: et totum veritas, quidquid de tela hujus mulieris procedit ("and it is all truth, whatever comes forth from this woman's web").
(printed under page 121)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 230
Ms. Colbertinus, laudabimus. Forte pro, laudavimus.
The Colbert manuscript: laudabimus. Perhaps for laudavimus.
(printed under page 121)
(2) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 230
In editis, nemo non videt. Abest, non, a Mss.
In the printed editions: nemo non videt. The word non is absent from the manuscripts.
(printed under page 121)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 231
Ms. Germanensis: Numquid prorsus vendidit? Alii tres: Nam quid prorsus vendidit.
The Saint-Germain manuscript: Numquid prorsus vendidit? ("Did she really sell at all?"). Three others: Nam quid prorsus vendidit ("For what indeed did she sell").
(printed under page 122)
(2) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 231
Sic Mss. aliquot. At editi, spiritualem amorem.
So several manuscripts. But the printed editions: spiritualem amorem ("spiritual love").
(printed under page 122)
(3) ‹anchor: diu tribulata› · call in col 231
Ms. Corbeiensis: Tunc laetata est: quia hic diu tribulata.
The Corbie manuscript: Tunc laetata est: quia hic diu tribulata ("Then she rejoiced, because here she was long afflicted").
(printed under page 122)
(1) ‹anchor: sentiens de Creatore› · call in col 232
Apud Ambrosium, non sentiens creaturam de Creatoris existere substantia. Id quidem opportune contra Manichaeos: sed secundum illud Decalogi praeceptum, Non accipies nomen Domini Dei tui in vanum, ubi commemorat Augustinus, solet de Filio Dei interpretari et Arianorum haeresim exinde refellere, uti facit nostra illa, quae in omnibus Mss. habetur, lectione. Vide supra, serm. 9, nn. 3 et 4.
In the Ambrose printing: non sentiens creaturam de Creatoris existere substantia ("not holding that the creature exists from the substance of the Creator"). That is indeed apt against the Manichees; but where Augustine recalls that second commandment of the Decalogue, You shall not take the name of the Lord your God in vain, he is accustomed to interpret it of the Son of God and to refute from it the heresy of the Arians, as he does in that reading of ours, which is found in all the manuscripts. See above, sermon 9, nos. 3 and 4.
(printed under page 122)
(2) ‹anchor: quemlibet propter me› · call in col 232
In editis omissa erant isthaec verba, quae ex Colbertino codice restituuntur, nec alium quemlibet propter me. Horum loco in Mss. aliquot habetur tantum, praeter me.
In the printed editions these words had been omitted, which are restored from the Colbert codex: nec alium quemlibet propter me ("nor anyone else whatever on my account"). In their place several manuscripts have only praeter me ("besides me").
(printed under page 122)
(3) ‹anchor: tantum acquisivit› · call in col 232
Mss. Sorbonici, exquisivit.
The Sorbonne manuscripts: exquisivit.
(printed under page 122)
(4) ‹anchor: Quid te jactas› · call in col 232
Sic Mss. Editi vero, quid te lactas?
So the manuscripts. The printed editions, however: quid te lactas? ("why do you beguile yourself?").
(printed under page 122)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 233
Liber cl. Audiamus ita vivamus in illa, et cum illa audiamus quemadmodum, etc.
The book cl.: Audiamus ita vivamus in illa, et cum illa audiamus quemadmodum, etc. ("Let us hear; let us so live in her, and with her let us hear how," etc.).
(printed under page 123)
(2) ‹anchor: ista natae sunt› · call in col 233
Editi, Quia et illae et istae natae sunt. Melius Mss., ex ista.
The printed editions: Quia et illae et istae natae sunt. Better the manuscripts: ex ista ("from her").
(printed under page 123)
(1) ‹anchor: infra te sunt› · call in col 234
Editi, inflatae sunt. At Colbertinus Ms. Infra te sunt. Magis ad sensum hujus versiculi, Tu autem superasti, etc.
The printed editions: inflatae sunt ("they are puffed up"). But the Colbert manuscript: Infra te sunt ("they are beneath you"), which is closer to the sense of this verse, Tu autem superasti, etc.
(printed under page 123)
(2) ‹anchor: ipsum botrum› · call in col 234
Ita in Mss. At in editis, Vide ipsum florem.
So in the manuscripts. But in the printed editions: Vide ipsum florem ("See the flower itself").
(printed under page 123)
(3) ‹anchor: ab hoc capite› · call in col 234
Editi Et ab hoc apice. At Mss., capite.
The printed editions: Et ab hoc apice ("And from this summit"). But the manuscripts: capite ("head").
(printed under page 123)
(4) ‹anchor: tot noctibus› · call in col 234
Sic Ms. Colbertinus. At editi, tot laudibus.
So the Colbert manuscript. But the printed editions: tot laudibus ("with so many praises").
(printed under page 123)