PL 39 · cols. 2104–2110
Appendix to Augustine's Sermones: Sermones supposititii, Sermones 174-195
Sermons CXCIV–CXCV
Migne Reading Room
PL 39 · cols. 2104–2110
Sermons CXCIV–CXCV
(a) ‹anchor: Sermo CXCIV› · call in col 2104
Alias, de Sanctis 18.
Formerly Sermon 18 de Sanctis.
(printed under page 314)
(b) ‹anchor: De Annuntiatione Dominica, II› · call in col 2104
In Appendice nunc primum collocatur. Dubium relinquunt Lovanienses, et Fulgentio a quibusdam tribui dicunt. Rejiciunt omnino ut falsum Verlinus et Vindingus. Nec injuria sane, tametsi in Breviario Romano et nonnullis aliis legatur sub Augustini nomine die 1 et 2 annuae solemnitatis propter Deiparae Nativitatem celebrandam institutae. Enimvero si de Nativitate B. Virginis, sicuti vere in manuscriptis nostris, uno excepto Corbeiensi, inscribitur, compositus fuit, auctorem habeat necesse est recentiorem Augustino, qui aliquoties testatur in Sermonibus de Nativitate Joannis Baptistae, hujus tantum et Christi Domini Nativitatem in Ecclesia aevo suo celebrari solitam. Sed in quamcumque B. Mariae diem referatur sermonis exordium; certe nullum ipsius Virginis festum exhibet Calendarium antiquum in Carthaginensi Ecclesia usque ad Augustini saltem obitum qui in eo consignatur, usitatum. Praeterea quod hic frigidissime num. 2 dicitur de Sabellianis, fingere illos quod Maria, non decursis novem a conceptione mensibus pepererit Christum, sed fortuito repererit parvulum, id neque modo refutatur, neque alias unquam refutatum vel commemoratum est ab Augustino: imo Patripassianos, qui sunt Sabelliani, dixisse ipsum Patrem natum ex femina, observat in serm. 52, n. 6. Nec praetereundum silentio est sermonem in duobus manuscriptis Germanensibus praeferre nomen Hieronymi: quo nomine peraeque indignus videtur. Opus quippe est imperiti alicujus consarcinatoris, qui huc congessit plures ad verbum sententias superiorum sermonum 119, 120, 121, necnon sermonis 208, de Assumptione B. Mariae. De num. 1 vid. serm. 120 a n. 2 usque ad 8, nisi quod ibi plura hinc inde inseruntur; de num. 2 confer serm. 208, de Assumpt. B. M. num. 4; de num. 3, vide serm. 120, n. 7, et serm. 121, n. 4; de eodem num. 3 et 4 vide serm. 119 Append., n. 2-4; de num. 5, serm. 208, de Assumpt. n. 11.
It is placed in the Appendix now for the first time. The Louvain editors leave it doubtful, and say some ascribe it to Fulgentius. Verlinus and Vindingus reject it outright as spurious. And not without reason, although in the Roman Breviary and some others it is read under Augustine's name on the first and second days of the yearly solemnity instituted to celebrate the Nativity of the Mother of God. For if it was composed for the Nativity of the Blessed Virgin, as in fact it is headed in our manuscripts (the Corbie one alone excepted), it must have an author later than Augustine, who testifies more than once in his Sermons on the Nativity of John the Baptist that in his time only John's nativity and that of Christ the Lord were customarily celebrated in the Church. But to whatever day of Blessed Mary the opening of the sermon is referred, certainly the ancient Calendar of the Church of Carthage shows no feast of the Virgin herself in use, at least down to Augustine's death, which is recorded in it. Moreover, what is said here most insipidly in no. 2 of the Sabellians, that they pretended Mary gave birth to Christ without nine months having run from the conception, but found the little one by chance, is neither refuted here nor ever refuted or mentioned elsewhere by Augustine; rather, he observes in Sermon 52, no. 6, that the Patripassians, who are Sabellians, said the Father himself was born of a woman. Nor should it be passed over in silence that in two Saint-Germain manuscripts the sermon bears the name of Jerome, a name of which it seems equally unworthy. For it is the work of some unskilled patcher, who has heaped up here word for word many sentences of the preceding sermons 119, 120, 121, and also of Sermon 208, on the Assumption of Blessed Mary. On no. 1 see Sermon 120 from no. 2 to 8, except that more is inserted there here and there; on no. 2 compare Sermon 208, on the Assumption of Blessed Mary, no. 4; on no. 3 see Sermon 120, no. 7, and Sermon 121, no. 4; on nos. 3 and 4 see also Appendix Sermon 119, nos. 2–4; on no. 5, Sermon 208, on the Assumption, no. 11.
(printed under page 314)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible on the foot image› · call in col 2105
Ita editi. Accedunt gr. duo, in quibus, solemnitate. Corbeiensis autem habet, conceptu. Alter item Corbeiensis cum Fossatensi, excessu. Michaelinus vero, Natali.
So the printed editions. Two gr. manuscripts agree, in which "solemnitate" (solemnity). But the Corbie manuscript has "conceptu" (conception). The other Corbie manuscript likewise, with the Saint-Maur-des-Fossés one, "excessu" (departure). The Mont-Saint-Michel manuscript, however, "Natali" (birthday).
(printed under page 315)
(2) ‹anchor: partum Evae evicit› · call in col 2105
Ita cb. Ms. et m., nisi quod in hoc est, errati, pro, laetitiae. In editis autem: Causam igitur invalescentis errati miraculum novi partus evicit.
So manuscripts cb. and m., except that in the latter there is "errati" (of the error) for "laetitiae" (of the joy). But in the printed editions: "The miracle of the new birth therefore overcame the cause of the prevailing error."
(printed under page 315)
(3) ‹anchor: turbaris modo› · call in col 2105
Et hic secuti sumus Ms. cb., cum in aliis libris sit quomodo supra serm. 120, n. 7, vitam quid tricas mundo?
Here too we have followed manuscript cb., whereas in the other books there is, as above in Sermon 120, no. 7, "why do you delay life for the world?"
(printed under page 315)
(4) ‹anchor: te, Domina› · call in col 2105
Forte, te Domino; ut supra, serm. 120, n. 7.
Perhaps "te Domino" (you, for the Lord); as above, Sermon 120, no. 7.
(printed under page 315)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible on the foot image› · call in col 2106
Hic editi contra fidem Mss. loco, tantae Virginis; substituebant, annuntiationis quae per Angelum hodie facta est ad aures Virginis.
Here the printed editions, against the authority of the manuscripts, in place of "tantae Virginis" (of so great a Virgin) substituted "of the annunciation which was made today by the Angel to the Virgin's ears."
(printed under page 315)
(2) ‹anchor: minister adveni› · call in col 2106
In Ms. m., nuntius.
In manuscript m.: "nuntius" (messenger).
(printed under page 315)
(1) ‹anchor: praemiorum (end of the parenthesis, "exspectatio praemiorum.)")› · call in col 2107
Verba hic parenthesi inclusa desunt in manuscriptis et in serm. 208, de Assumptione.
The words enclosed here in parentheses are lacking in the manuscripts and in Sermon 208, on the Assumption.
(printed under page 316)
(2) ‹anchor: tuam commemorationem› · call in col 2107
Ita Ms. cb. cum editis. Alii, tuum Natale. Et infra, in serm. 208, de Assumptione, tuum nomen.
So manuscript cb. with the printed editions. Others: "tuum Natale" (your birthday). And below, in Sermon 208, on the Assumption: "tuum nomen" (your name).
(printed under page 316)
(3) ‹anchor: pretium ferre mundi› · call in col 2107
Editi, Redemptorem ferre mundi. Ms. m., prolem ferre mundi. Unus ex gr., benedictam prolem proferre mundo. Alter gr., benedictam precem proferre mundo: per quae verba in iisdem Mss. sermo clauditur. Secuti sumus Ms. cb., in quo haec insuper additur clausula, praestante Dei et hominis Filio, quem portasti in utero Redemptorem ac Dominum nostrum Jesum Christum, qui cum Patre ac Spiritu sancto unus Deus in Trinitate vivit et regnat per omnia saecula saeculorum. Amen.
The printed editions: "to bear the Redeemer of the world." Manuscript m.: "to bear the offspring of the world." One of the gr. manuscripts: "to bring forth blessed offspring for the world." The other gr.: "to bring forth a blessed prayer for the world," and with these words the sermon closes in those same manuscripts. We have followed manuscript cb., in which this closing clause is added besides: "by the gift of the Son of God and man, whom you bore in your womb, our Redeemer and Lord Jesus Christ, who with the Father and the Holy Spirit, one God in Trinity, lives and reigns for all ages of ages. Amen."
(printed under page 316)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon heading, Sermo CXCV)› · call in col 2107
Olim, de Tempore 18; et post, in Appendice 25.
Formerly Sermon 18 de Tempore; and later, no. 25 in the Appendix.
(printed under page 316)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon heading)› · call in col 2107
Hominis est ineruditi, judicio Lovaniensium. In codicibus admodum vetustis invenitur: unus ex illis Corbeiensis Ambrosium, caeteri fere Augustinum auctorem, sed immerito, designant.
It is the work of an unlearned man, in the judgement of the Louvain editors. It is found in very old codices: one of them, from Corbie, names Ambrose as its author, nearly all the others Augustine, but undeservedly.
(none) · col 2108
(none)
(no footnotes at the foot of col 2108)
(printed under page 316)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible on the foot image› · call in col 2109
Mss. potiores, post verbum, sentiebat, subdunt, secumque diu, etc., omissis verbis intermediis.
The better manuscripts, after the word "sentiebat" (he perceived), add "secumque diu" (and long with himself), etc., leaving out the words in between.
(printed under page 317)
(2) ‹anchor: not visible on the foot image› · call in col 2109
In Mss. nonnullis, et regale sacerdotium praenoscebam. In editis autem, quia David filium me esse sciebam.
In some manuscripts: "and I foreknew the royal priesthood." But in the printed editions: "because I knew I was a child of David."
(printed under page 317)
(3) ‹anchor: sed naevum› · call in col 2109
Mss. vetustiores, necem. At. n., nefas.
The older manuscripts: "necem" (death). At. n.: "nefas" (sacrilege).
(printed under page 317)
(4) ‹anchor: cum jam esset alterius› · call in col 2109
Ita Mss. potiores. Quidam alii, ut esset adultera. Editi adulterii rea. In n. codice, id esset adulterium, cum jam esset mysterium.
So the better manuscripts. Some others: "that she was an adulteress." The printed editions: "guilty of adultery." In codex n.: "that it was adultery, when it was already a mystery."
(printed under page 317)
(none) · col 2110
(none)
(no footnotes called in this unit's text in col 2110; the notes (a) and (b) at the foot of page 317 are called in the title of Sermon 196, a later unit, and are not set here)
(printed under page 317)