PL 39 · cols. 2124–2127
Appendix to Augustine's Sermones: Sermones supposititii, Sermones 196-210
Sermons CCIV–CCVI
Migne Reading Room
PL 39 · cols. 2124–2127
Sermons CCIV–CCVI
(a) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCIV title)› · call in col 2124
Alias, de Sanctis 25.
Elsewhere, Sermon 25 on the Saints.
(printed under page 324)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCIV subtitle)› · call in col 2124
In Appendice nunc primum collocatur. Dubium relinquunt Lovanienses, rejiciunt ut falsum Verlinus et Vindingus. Leoni in veteri codice Corbeiensi adscribitur, in aliis quibusdam Augustino: sed horum sane doctorum eruditione et gravitate indignus est. Stilo parum distat a superioribus sermonibus 187 et 195. Habet verba etiam nonnulla sermonis proxime subsequentis.
It is now placed in the Appendix for the first time. The Louvain editors leave it doubtful; Verlinus and Vindingus reject it as false. In an old Corbie manuscript it is ascribed to Leo, in certain others to Augustine; but it is surely unworthy of the learning and weight of these doctors. In style it differs little from Sermons 187 and 195 above. It also has some words of the sermon immediately following.
(printed under page 324)
(1) ‹anchor: vacuam cortinam› · call in col 2125
Ita Mss. r. et gr. At f., sinuosa volumina, et vocat cohortem. In editis autem, ut alii quam plures hujus sermonis loci, sic et iste vitiose reddebatur in hunc modum, sinum lini, volvit in se vacuam cortinam.
So manuscripts r. and gr. But f. reads "winding coils, and calls the band." In the printed editions, however, like a great many other places in this sermon, this one too was given faultily, thus: "the fold of the line, he rolled up into himself an empty net."
(printed under page 325)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCV title)› · call in col 2125
Alias, de Sanctis 28.
Elsewhere, Sermon 28 on the Saints.
(printed under page 325)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCV subtitle)› · call in col 2125
In Appendice nunc primum collocatur. Ex Lovaniensium censura dubius, ex Verlini autem et Vindingi sententia supposititius est. Non peritiori stilo conscriptus, quam sermo superior, quo cum sermone in sententiis et verbis quibusdam convenit.
It is now placed in the Appendix for the first time. By the Louvain editors' judgement it is doubtful; in the opinion of Verlinus and Vindingus, spurious. It is written in a style no more skilled than the preceding sermon, with which it agrees in certain thoughts and words.
(printed under page 325)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop› · call in col 2126 (above the crop)
Editi, mugit populus; Ms., rugiente populo: et mox, militia conqueritur; pro, provincia. Floriacensem secuti sumus.
The printed editions read "the people bellows"; the manuscript, "with the people roaring"; and just after, "militia conqueritur" (the host complains) instead of "provincia". We have followed the Fleury manuscript.
(printed under page 325)
(2) ‹anchor: digerens digereris› · call in col 2126
Ms. r., digeres; f., digereris. Mox uterque, adhibes ergo fidem video; vel potius, Judaeo.
Manuscript r. reads "digeres"; f., "digereris". Just after, both read "adhibes ergo fidem video" (so you give faith, I see); or rather, "Judaeo" (to the Jew).
(printed under page 325)
(1) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop› · call in col 2127 (above the crop)
In Ms. r., fulget supplicium.
In manuscript r., "the punishment shines."
(printed under page 326)
(2) ‹anchor: Cleophas dixerunt› · call in col 2127
Editi, duo illi discipuli dixerunt. At cb. Ms., Amahus et Cleophas dixerunt: quomodo etiam habet idem sermo apud Ambrosium. Accedit codex t. in quo, Emahus et Cleophas: et sic jam supra in sermone 86, ad eumdem locum. Ambrosius porro in Lucae caput 24, eosdem discipulos Amaonem et Cleopham vocat.
The printed editions read "those two disciples said." But manuscript cb. reads "Amahus and Cleophas said," as the same sermon also has it in Ambrose. Manuscript t. agrees, reading "Emahus and Cleophas"; and so already above in Sermon 86, at the same place. Ambrose, moreover, on Luke chapter 24, calls these same disciples Amaon and Cleophas.
(printed under page 326)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCVI title)› · call in col 2127
Olim, de Sanctis 30; et post, in Appendice 80.
Formerly Sermon 30 on the Saints; and later, Sermon 80 in the Appendix.
(printed under page 326)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible in the crop (Sermo CCVI subtitle)› · call in col 2127
Dignus est qui legatur, Lovaniensium judicio. Inter Ambrosii Sermones reperitur in excusis, ipsique in Ms. Corbeiensi et in Theodericensi inscribitur. Confer ad ejus Commentaria in Lucam et ad sermones hujus Appendicis 86, 87, Commentariis iisdem plurimum congruentes. Caeterum conclusio ab istis verbis, « Nos vero, fratres dilectissimi, » etc., desumpta est ex Caesarii sermone de Martyribus, qui est infra 224.
In the Louvain editors' judgement it is worth reading. It is found among Ambrose's sermons in the printed editions, and is inscribed to him in the Corbie manuscript and in the Thierry manuscript. Compare his Commentary on Luke and Sermons 86 and 87 of this Appendix, which agree very closely with that Commentary. The conclusion, however, from the words "But we, dearest brethren," etc., is taken from Caesarius's sermon on the Martyrs, which is below, no. 224.
(printed under page 326)