PL 39 · cols. 1655–1658
Augustine, Sermones 364-375 (Classis V, Sermones dubii)
Sermons CCCLXIX–CCCLXX
Migne Reading Room
PL 39 · cols. 1655–1658
Sermons CCCLXIX–CCCLXX
(1) ‹anchor: Quisquis hunc diem miraris› · call in col 1655
1 Mss., in die miraris.
The manuscripts read "you wonder at in the day".
(printed under page 90)
(2) ‹anchor: Magi mutati› · call in col 1655
2 Sic meliores Mss. At editi, Magi invitati.
So the better manuscripts. But the printed editions read "the Magi invited".
(*) ‹anchor: SERMO CCCLXIX› · call in col 1655 * Collatus ad tres cb. et duos n. ad f. gr. r. t. et ad Am. Er. Par. Lov.
Collated against the three cb. and the two n. manuscripts, against f., gr., r., t., and against the Amerbach, Erasmus, Paris and Louvain editions.
(printed under page 90)
(a) ‹anchor: SERMO CCCLXIX› · call in col 1655
(printed under page 90) (a) Alias, de Tempore 5.
Formerly, De Tempore 5.
(printed under page 90)
(b) ‹anchor: De Nativitate Domini, I› · call in col 1655
(printed under page 90) (b) Lovanienses dubitant an sit Augustini. Contra, Vindingus dicit nihil habere unde ipsi abjudicetur, imo assertum Augustino esse auctoritate antiqui scriptoris, in Conflictu Arnobii et Serapionis, ad cujus operis finem sermo iste totus recitatur. Verum Conflictus hujus commentitii auctor (ipsius etiam Vindingi conjectura in critico Augustiniano, tom. 6) Vigilius episcopus non meretur deinceps ullam hac in re fidem, postquam suas lucubrationes contra Arianos ementito superiorum Patrum nomine publicasse convictus est. Imitari stilum Augustini studet, probaturus eo sermone praedicatas ab ipso duas nativitates Christi. Confer Appendicis sermonem 117.
The Louvain editors doubt whether it is Augustine's. Vindingus, on the contrary, says that it has nothing by which it should be denied him; indeed, that it is claimed for Augustine on the authority of an ancient writer, in the Conflict of Arnobius and Serapion, at the end of which work this sermon is quoted entire. But the author of this fictitious Conflict, Bishop Vigilius (by the conjecture of Vindingus himself too, in the Critica Augustiniana, vol. 6), deserves no further credit in this matter, since he was convicted of publishing his works against the Arians under the falsely assumed name of earlier Fathers. He strives to imitate Augustine's style, meaning to prove by this sermon that the two nativities of Christ were preached by Augustine himself. Compare Sermon 117 of the Appendix.
(printed under page 90)
(1) ‹anchor: Ab omnibus› · call in col 1656
1 Hic in excusis et aliquot Mss. additum, segregata: vel, aliena.
Here the printed editions and some manuscripts add "set apart", or "estranged".
(printed under page 90)
(1) ‹anchor: quod voverunt› · call in col 1657
1 Lov., voverat; refragantibus editis caeteris et manuscriptis.
The Louvain edition reads "she had vowed", against the other editions and the manuscripts.
(*) ‹anchor: not visible (heading of the sermon)› · call in col 1657 * Emendatus ad tres cb. ad f. n. r. t. v. et ad Am. Er. Par. Lov.
Corrected against the three cb. manuscripts, against f., n., r., t., v., and against the Amerbach, Erasmus, Paris and Louvain editions.
(printed under page 91)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible (heading of the sermon)› · call in col 1657
(printed under page 91) (a) Alias, de Tempore 20.
Formerly, De Tempore 20.
(printed under page 91)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible (heading of the sermon)› · call in col 1657
(printed under page 91) (b) Dubius nobis hic sermo est, propter genus dicendi incultum ac minus accuratum. Exempli gratia, post recensitos quatuor modos conditi hominis, quod subjicitur, « sed ista quarta conditio liberavit tres. Prima enim et secunda ruerunt, tertiam de ruina genuerunt, » etc., perplexe dictum est ac improprie. Nonnulla hic reperies consimilia sermonum verorum Augustini de Natali Domini.
This sermon is doubtful to us, because of its unpolished and less careful manner of speaking. For example, after the four ways in which man was made have been listed, what is added, "but this fourth condition set the three free. For the first and second fell, they begot the third out of the ruin," etc., is said confusedly and improperly. You will find here some things very like the genuine sermons of Augustine on the Lord's Nativity.
(printed under page 91)
(c) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 1657
(printed under page 91) (c) Hinc sermo incipit in multis libris.
In many books the sermon begins here.
(printed under page 91)
(d) ‹anchor: Perveniunt et viduae› · call in col 1657
(printed under page 91) (d) Vide serm. 184, cap. 2, et serm. 192, cap. 2.
See Sermon 184, ch. 2, and Sermon 192, ch. 2.
(printed under page 91)