PL 4 · cols. 264–267
Cyprianus, Epistolae II-XXI
Letter XV
Migne Reading Room
PL 4 · cols. 264–267
Letter XV
(e) ‹congressionibus› · call in col 264
Congressibus Oxon.
"Congressibus" ("encounters") Oxon.
STEPH. BALUZII NOTAE. (Baluze) ‹Timorem Dei› · lemma note
(continued) mini suggerere nostra mediocritas potuit. Postea vero quam, etc.
(Baluze) ‹Confortandos› · lemma note Confortandos. Rigaltius posuit confirmandos, contra omnium veterum codicum et editionum fidem. Miror autem Anglos, qui lectionem quam nos revocamus inveniebant etiam in vetustis exemplaribus suis, retinuisse quod erat scriptum in editione Rigaltii. Reinhartus reposuit confortandos.
"Confortandos" (to be strengthened). Rigault printed "confirmandos" (to be confirmed), against the faith of all the old manuscripts and editions. I am surprised that the English, who found the reading we restore in their own very old copies too, kept what was written in Rigault's edition. Reinhart restored "confortandos."
(Baluze) ‹Diaconis non defuit› · lemma note Diaconis non defuit. Erant illi in tertio sacerdotio constituti, ut in libro primo ait Optatus, et multa facere poterant in absentia episcoporum et presbyterorum. Itaque recte ait Cyprianus non defuisse illis sacerdotii vigorem. Vide epistolam Augustini presbyteri ad Valerium.
"Diaconis non defuit" (was not lacking to the deacons). They were set in the third priesthood, as Optatus says in his first book, and could do many things in the absence of bishops and presbyters. So Cyprian rightly says that the vigour of the priesthood was not lacking to them. See the letter of Augustine, then a presbyter, to Valerius.
(Baluze) ‹Animum› · lemma note Animum. Hanc vocem, quae deerat in aliis editionibus, et deest in multis codicibus antiquis, Manutiana editio addidit. Inveni autem illam in octo codicibus manuscriptis. Rigaltius posuit animos.
"Animum" (the mind). This word, which was missing in other editions and is missing in many ancient manuscripts, the Manutius edition added. I found it, however, in eight manuscripts. Rigault printed "animos" (the minds).
(Baluze) ‹III.— Sive aliquo incitatore› · lemma note III. — Sive aliquo incitatore. In libro Fuxensi legitur, sine aliquo disputatore. In Divionensi et in uno Remigiano, nescio quo disputatore incitante.
III. — "Sive aliquo incitatore" (or at someone's instigation). In the Foix book one reads "without any disputer." In the Dijon one and in one Saint-Remi manuscript, "at the urging of some disputer or other."
(Baluze) ‹Proruerent› · lemma note Proruerent. Ita omnes veteres libri et editiones, etiam ea quae est Reinharti. Codex Veronensis habet prorumperent. Hinc ergo orta est mutatio quam Rigaltius invexit in hunc locum.
"Proruerent" (they rushed forth). So all the old books and editions, even Reinhart's. The Verona manuscript has "prorumperent" (they burst forth). From here, then, arose the change that Rigault brought into this passage.
(Baluze) ‹Epist. XV.— I. Celerinus› · lemma note EPIST. XV. — I. Celerinus. Cujus egregias laudes commemorat sanctus Cyprianus Epist. 34, ad clerum et plebem (pag. 47), et cujus perhonorifica mentio habetur in epistola Cornelii Papae ad Fabium episcopum Antiochenum apud Eusebium, lib. VI, cap. 43, Historiae ecclesiasticae, scripta, ut opinor, eo tempore quo Celerinus erat apud Cornelium. Omnino enim sentio cum illustrissimo Cardinale Baronio Celerinum in hac Cornelii epistola laudatum, eum esse qui fuit lector ecclesiae Carthaginensis. Illud autem obiter admonebo, Marianum Victorium in annotationibus suis ad opera sancti Hieronymi confudisse hunc Fabium episcopum Antiochenum cum Flaviano episcopo Constantinopolitano, cujus multa mentio in concilio Ephesino et in Chalcedonensi. In hunc errorem inductus 401 est vir doctissimus ex falsa lectione quae antiquitus irrepsit in librum sancti Hieronymi de Viris illustribus, ubi scriptum est Cornelium Papam scripsisse quatuor epistolas ad Flavianum episcopum Antiochenum ; pro quo vetera illius libri exemplaria et postrema Hieronymianorum operum editio recte ha- (continues)
Letter XV. — I. "Celerinus." Saint Cyprian records his outstanding praises in Letter 34, to the clergy and people (p. 47), and he is mentioned with great honour in the letter of Pope Cornelius to Fabius, bishop of Antioch, in Eusebius, Ecclesiastical History book 6, chapter 43, written, I believe, at the time when Celerinus was with Cornelius. For I entirely agree with the most illustrious Cardinal Baronius that the Celerinus praised in this letter of Cornelius is the one who was a lector of the church of Carthage. I shall note in passing, however, that Mariano Vittori, in his annotations on the works of Saint Jerome, confused this Fabius, bishop of Antioch, with Flavian, bishop of Constantinople, who is much mentioned in the councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon. That most learned man was led into this error [the "401" printed here is as in Migne] by a false reading that crept in long ago into Saint Jerome's book On Illustrious Men, where it is written that Pope Cornelius wrote four letters to Flavian, bishop of Antioch; for which the old copies of that book and the latest edition of Jerome's works rightly ha- (continues)
(printed under page 127)
LECTIONES VARIANTES. (printed under page 128)
(a) ‹charitatem› · call in col 265
De charitate Corb.
"Of charity" Corb.
(printed under page 128)
(b) ‹adhaeremus› · call in col 265
Inhaeremus Oxon.
"Inhaeremus" ("we cling") Oxon.
(printed under page 128)
(c) ‹charitas vestra› · call in col 265
Nostra Ebor.
"Nostra" ("our") Ebor.
(printed under page 128)
(d) ‹separari› · call in col 265
Separari enim Lam.
"For to be separated" Lam.
(printed under page 128)
(e) ‹me affectio› · call in col 265
Me hic N. Fab.
"Me here" N. Fab.
(printed under page 128)
(f) ‹faventiam› · call in col 265
Domini faventiam Lam. Bod. 3. NC. 1. 2. Lin.
"The Lord's favour" Lam., Bod. 3, NC. 1, 2, Lin.
(printed under page 128)
(g) ‹spirantes› · call in col 265
Sperantes Bod. 1. Vat. Thu. Corb.
"Sperantes" ("hoping") Bod. 1, Vat., Thu., Corb.
(printed under page 128)
(h) ‹non trahitis› · call in col 265
Subtrahitis Bod. 1. Thu. Foss. Corb.
"Subtrahitis" ("you withdraw") Bod. 1, Thu., Foss., Corb.
(printed under page 128) (Footnote (i), "Manens in praeliis Lam.", has its call in col 266 at "manens" and is listed in n266.)
(i) ‹manens› · call in col 266
Manens in praeliis Lam.
"Remaining in battles" Lam.
(printed under page 128)
(j) ‹pensabatis› · call in col 266
Pensatis Bod. 1. Thu.
"Pensatis" ("you weigh / make up for") Bod. 1, Thu.
(printed under page 128)
(k) ‹conspicitis› · call in col 266
Perspicitis Bod. 1. Corb.
"Perspicitis" ("you see clearly") Bod. 1, Corb.
(printed under page 128) STEPH. BALUZII NOTAE. (Baluze) ‹Epist. XV.— I. Celerinus› · lemma note
(continued) bent scriptum nomen Fabii. Hujus porro Celerini epistola ad Lucianum extat infra inter epistolas sancti Cypriani. Vide notas ad Epistolam XXXIV. Alterius Celerini, qui pater erat Ageruchiae, meminit sanctus Hieronymus in epistola ad Ageruchiam ; alterius inscriptio vetus, edita a Reinesio, pag. 161. Celerini praetoris nomen extat in historia passionis sanctorum Chrysanthi et Dariae apud Surium, tom. V.
(Baluze) ‹Vos in illo› · lemma note Vos in illo. Ruricius, lib. II, epist. 32 : Frater et compresbyter noster Capillutus dupliciter hac vice nobis gratus apparuit, dum et ipse nobis jamdiu desideratus occurrit, et quamdam vestri praesentiam per vestras litteras repraesentat.
"Vos in illo" (you in him). Ruricius, book 2, letter 32: "Our brother and fellow presbyter Capillutus appeared doubly welcome to us this time, since he himself, long desired by us, came to meet us, and by your letter he brings before us a kind of presence of yourself."
(Baluze) ‹Ornamenta› · lemma note Ornamenta. Ita Rigaltius, propterea reprehensus in editione Anglicana. Et tamen auctorem hujus lectionis habuit editionem Manutianam, in qua ita scriptum est, eique scripturae consentiunt novem vetera exemplaria. Sane vox hortamento, quam praeferunt veteres editiones et decem item vetera exemplaria, bona esse potest. Illam ergo praetulit Reinhartus. Adjuvari autem potest ex hoc loco libri de Lapsis (pag. 183) : Episcopi plurimi, quos et hortamento esse oportet caeteris et exemplo.
"Ornamenta" (ornaments). So Rigault, for which he was blamed in the English edition. Yet he had as authority for this reading the Manutius edition, in which it is so written, and nine old copies agree with that text. Indeed the word "hortamento" (for an encouragement), which the old editions and likewise ten old copies show, can be good. Reinhart therefore preferred it. And it can be supported by this place in the book On the Lapsed (p. 183): "Very many bishops, who ought to be an encouragement and an example to the rest."
(Baluze) ‹In secessu› · lemma note In secessu. Duo libri veteres habent in secreto, quod videtur melius. Et tamen mutare noluimus, quia omnes fere libri veteres et omnes editiones habent in secessu.
"In secessu" (in retirement). Two old books have "in secreto" (in secret), which seems better. Yet we would not change it, because almost all the old books and all the editions have "in secessu."
(Baluze) ‹A Domino faventiam› · lemma note A Domino faventiam. Codices Carnotensis et Beccensis habent Domini faventiam. Festus : Faventia bonam orationem significat. Accius Oenom., apud Nonium Marcellum : Omnibus faustis acceptam habeant faventiam. Sic enim recte hunc locum emendavit Hadrianus Junius.
"A Domino faventiam" (favour from the Lord). The Chartres and Bec manuscripts have "Domini faventiam" (the Lord's favour). Festus: "Faventia means auspicious speech." Accius, Oenomaus, in Nonius Marcellus: "Let them hold the favour accepted with all good omens." For so Hadrianus Junius rightly emended this passage.
(Baluze) ‹Spirantes› · lemma note Spirantes. Codex Carnotensis, sperantes : Metensis sancti Arnulphi, spirantes vel sperantes.
"Spirantes" (breathing). The Chartres manuscript, "sperantes" (hoping); the Metz manuscript of Saint-Arnoul, "spirantes or sperantes."
(Baluze) ‹Mora ipsa passionis› · lemma note Mora ipsa passionis. Codices Fuxensis et Eligianus, hora ipsa. Corbeiensis, ad horam ipsam.
"Mora ipsa passionis" (by the very delay of the passion). The Foix and Saint-Éloi manuscripts, "hora ipsa" (in the very hour). The Corbie one, "ad horam ipsam" (at the very hour).
(Baluze) ‹Non trahitis› · lemma note Non trahitis. Codex Carnotensis, subtrahitis.
"Non trahitis" (you do not draw out). The Chartres manuscript, "subtrahitis" (you withdraw).
(Baluze) ‹II.— Honoris annui› · lemma note II. — Honoris annui. Vetus Remigianus, annuo claritatis honore.
II. — "Honoris annui" (of the yearly honour). The old Saint-Remi manuscript, "with the yearly honour of renown."
(Baluze) ‹Signata est› · lemma note Signata est. Codex sancti Arnulphi, signatur.
"Signata est" (was marked). The Saint-Arnoul manuscript, "signatur" (is marked).
(Baluze) ‹Horribiles caeteris› · lemma note Horribiles caeteris. Codex Carnotensis, carceris vel caeteris.
"Horribiles caeteris" (dreadful to others). The Chartres manuscript, "carceris vel caeteris" (of the prison, or to others).
(Baluze) ‹Mensium› · lemma note Mensium. Veteres libri habent mensuum. Quo etiam modo saepe scriptum vidi in vetustis exemplaribus manuscriptis aliorum veterum scriptorum. Mensum vero pro mensuum frequenter scriptum est in Codice Theodosiano. Mensum quoque legitur apud A. Gellium, lib. I, cap. 25. Vide annotationes Dionysii Lambini in secundam Verrinam Ciceronis.
"Mensium" (of the months). The old books have "mensuum." I have often seen it so written also in very old manuscript copies of other ancient writers. "Mensum," moreover, is frequently written for "mensuum" in the Theodosian Code. "Mensum" is read also in Aulus Gellius, book 1, chapter 25. See Denys Lambin's annotations on Cicero's second Verrine.
(Baluze) ‹Hibernum› · lemma note Hibernum. Antea editum erat tempus hibernum. Ego sustuli vocem tempus, quia plerique codices illam non habent, ideoque videtur esse ex glossemate et quia antiqui dicebant hibernum tantum. Seneca Epist. XV : Una Hannibalem hiberna solverunt. Tertullianus, lib. I adversus Marcionem : Totus annus hibernum est. Sunt etiam alia exempla. Sed ista sufficiunt. Vide notas ad Capitularia, pag. 1185.
"Hibernum" (the winter). Formerly "tempus hibernum" (the winter season) had been printed. I removed the word "tempus," because most manuscripts do not have it, and so it seems to come from a gloss, and because the ancients said simply "hibernum." Seneca, Letter 15: "One winter's quarters undid Hannibal." Tertullian, Against Marcion book 1: "The whole year is winter." There are other examples too. But these suffice. See the notes on the Capitularies, p. 1185.
(Baluze) ‹Pensabitis› · lemma note Pensabitis. Codex sancti Arnulphi, pensatis. Quod videtur melius.
"Pensabitis" (you will make up for). The Saint-Arnoul manuscript, "pensatis" (you make up for). That seems better.
(Baluze) ‹Aderant› · lemma note Aderant. Ita plerique libri veteres. In quinque tamen et in antiquis editionibus scriptum est adhaerebant. Morellius edidit adhaerent.
"Aderant" (were present). So most of the old books. In five, however, and in the ancient editions is written "adhaerebant" (clung). Morel printed "adhaerent" (cling).
(Baluze) ‹Metistis› · lemma note Metistis. Codices Carnotensis et sancti Arnulphi, metitis.
"Metistis" (you have reaped). The Chartres and Saint-Arnoul manuscripts, "metitis" (you reap).
(Baluze) ‹Purgati› · lemma note Purgati. Veteres editiones, etiam Erasmica et Manutiana, praeferunt probati. Ita etiam multi veteres libri. Pamelius maluit purgati, nullum tamen veterem librum laudans. Nos secuti sumus illius emendationem, quia credidimus illam esse bonam, eamque confirmatam vidimus auctoritate aliquorum (continues)
"Purgati" (cleansed). The old editions, even those of Erasmus and Manutius, show "probati" (proved). So too many old books. Pamelius preferred "purgati," though citing no old book. We have followed his emendation, because we believed it to be good and saw it confirmed by the authority of some (continues)
(printed under page 128)
LECTIONES VARIANTES (printed under page 129)
(a) ‹temporis› · call in col 267
Fugendi temporis Lam.
"Of the time of flight": Lambeth MS.
(printed under page 129)
(b) ‹comitum glorias› · call in col 267
Comitum gloriam Pem. Lin. Ebor. NC. 1, 2.
"The glory of your companions" (singular): Pembroke, Lincoln and York MSS, New College MSS 1 and 2.
(printed under page 129)
(c) ‹vestra pugna› · call in col 267
Confessio Thu. Bod. 1.
"Confession" (for "fight"): Thuanus MS, Bodleian MS 1.
(printed under page 129)
(d) ‹qui vicerit coronetur› · call in col 267
Honoretur Man. Voss. 1. 3. M. R. Thu. Foss. Corb. Vicerint honorentur Bod. 1. 3.
"Be honoured" (for "be crowned"): Manutius's edition, Vossius MSS 1 and 3, Morel, Rigault, Thuanus, Fossatensis and Corbie MSS. "Those who have conquered be honoured": Bodleian MSS 1 and 3.
(printed under page 129)