PL 61 · cols. 343–349
Paulinus of Nola, Letters
Letter XXXIII
Migne Reading Room
PL 61 · cols. 343–349
Letter XXXIII
Scripture references (printed under page 175)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343
Prov. XIV, 4, juxta LXX.
Proverbs 14:4, according to the Septuagint.
(printed under page 175)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343
Matth. XXI, 13; Luc. XIX, 46.
Matthew 21:13; Luke 19:46.
(printed under page 175)
(c) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343
I Cor. V, 7.
1 Corinthians 5:7.
(printed under page 175)
(d) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343
Johan. V, 2.
John 5:2.
(printed under page 175)
(e) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343
Psal. CII, 3.
Psalm 102:3.
(printed under page 175)
(f) ‹anchor: grabatum illud tollimus› · call in col 343
Johan. V, 8.
John 5:8.
(printed under page 175)
(g) ‹anchor: miserando susciperet› · call in col 343
Isai. LIII, 4.
Isaiah 53:4.
(printed under page 175)
(h) ‹anchor: non manufactam› · call in col 343
II Cor. V, 1; Psal. CXVII, 15, sec. Psalt. Rom.
2 Corinthians 5:1; Psalm 117:15, according to the Roman Psalter.
(printed under page 175)
(i) ‹anchor: cum Domino erimus› · call in col 343
I Thess. IV, 16.
1 Thessalonians 4:16.
(printed under page 175)
(j) ‹anchor: manifestavit mihi› · call in col 343
II Cor. II, 14.
2 Corinthians 2:14.
(printed under page 175)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343 or 344
Ms. Reg., quae si audiat.
The Royal manuscript has "quae si audiat".
(printed under page 175)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 343 or 344
Ita ms. Vien. et edit. Chifflet., favente edit. Schot. Alii codices, conferam.
So the Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition, with the support of Schott's edition. Other manuscripts have "conferam" (the word is blurred on the scan).
(printed under page 175)
Scribit Alethio qui aliquid operis a Paulino poposcerat, et dicit se minus idoneum qui ejus satiare valeat desiderium. Is Alethius postea in episcopatu Cadurcensi successit Florentio fratri. (Vide Dissert. 3, num. 2.)
He writes to Alethius, who had asked Paulinus for some piece of work, and says that he is hardly equal to satisfying his desire. This Alethius afterwards succeeded his brother Florentius in the see of Cahors. (See Dissertation 3, no. 2.)
<!-- note: Argumentum of Epistola XXXIII. (none) unsure otherwise. -->
(k) ‹anchor: unde tale› · call in col 344
Matth. XII, 35.
Matthew 12:35.
(printed under page 175)
(l) ‹anchor: quantos postulas› · call in col 344
Luc. XI, 5.
Luke 11:5.
(printed under page 175)
(m) ‹anchor: vivae sitiens› · call in col 344
Johan. VII, 38.
John 7:38.
(printed under page 175)
(n) ‹anchor: eloquii suavitate› · call in col 344
Exod. XV, 25.
Exodus 15:25.
(printed under page 175)
(o) ‹anchor: percusso cordis› · call in col 344
Exod. XVII, 6.
Exodus 17:6.
Editors' notes (*) ‹anchor: EPISTOLA XXXIII (heading)› · call in col 343 Scripta videtur anno 403.
It seems to have been written in the year 403.
(**) ‹anchor: XXXIV SERMO (heading)› · call in col 344 Alias Epistol. 34. Forte anno 403, et missus cum superiore epistola.
Formerly Letter 34. Perhaps of the year 403, and sent with the preceding letter.
(printed under page 175)
(c) ‹anchor: unde› · call in col 344
Sic ms. codex Vien. cum edit. Chiffl. Alii, s[...]os.
So the Vienna manuscript, with Chifflet's edition. Others have a word beginning "s" and ending "-os" that is illegible on the scan.
(printed under page 175)
(d) ‹anchor: impensae mihi› · call in col 344
Ita emendavimus ex ms. Vien. et editis Chiffl. et Schot. Ms. Reg. cum tribus editis, exundarent, dulcescere. Rosv., exundanter dulcescere.
So we have corrected it from the Vienna manuscript and the editions of Chifflet and Schott. The Royal manuscript, with three editions, has "exundarent, dulcescere"; Rosweyde, "exundanter dulcescere".
(printed under page 175)
(e) ‹anchor: prophetae percusso› · call in col 344
Ita omnes codices praeter Vatic. et Rosv., in quibus corde.
So all the manuscripts except the Vatican one and Rosweyde, which have "corde".
(printed under page 175)
(f) ‹anchor: pabulum inferre,› · call in col 344
Sic reposuimus ex ms. codice Viennensi, edit. Chifflet. et Latin. Ante erat proclivi.
So we have restored it from the Vienna manuscript and the editions of Chifflet and Latinius. Before, it read "proclivi".
(printed under page 175)
Scripture references (printed under page 176)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345
Prov. XIV, 31, et XVII, 5.
Proverbs 14:31 and 17:5.
(printed under page 176)
(b) ‹anchor: Deum fenerat› · call in col 345
Prov. XIX, 17.
Proverbs 19:17.
(printed under page 176)
(c) ‹anchor: Dei fenus exercens› · call in col 345
Matth. XIII, 45.
Matthew 13:45.
(printed under page 176)
(d) ‹anchor: facere idipsum› · call in col 345
Gal. II, 10.
Galatians 2:10.
(printed under page 176)
(e) ‹anchor: auferre possumus› · call in col 345
I Tim. VI, 7.
1 Timothy 6:7.
(printed under page 176)
(f) ‹anchor: non acceperis› · call in col 345
I Cor. IV, 7.
1 Corinthians 4:7.
(printed under page 176)
(g) ‹anchor: nobis credita est› · call in col 345
I Cor. IX, 17.
1 Corinthians 9:17.
(printed under page 176)
(h) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Matth. XXV, 14.
Matthew 25:14.
(printed under page 176)
(i) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Matth. XXV, 21.
Matthew 25:21.
(printed under page 176)
(j) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Luc. XIX, 21.
Luke 19:21.
(printed under page 176)
(k) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Matth. XXV, 29, Luc. XIX, 26.
Matthew 25:29; Luke 19:26.
(printed under page 176)
(l) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Marc. XII, 43; Luc. XXI, 3 et 4.
Mark 12:43; Luke 21:3–4.
(printed under page 176)
(a) ‹anchor: locata› · call in col 345
Ita emendavimus ex mss. codicibus Reg. et Vien. et editis Grav., Schot. et Chiffl. Alii duo editi, pertineat. Ed. Rosv., perniteat.
So we have corrected it from the Royal and Vienna manuscripts and the editions of Gravius, Schott and Chifflet. Two other editions have "pertineat"; Rosweyde's edition, "perniteat".
(printed under page 176)
(b) ‹anchor: quod studui› · call in col 345
Ita Scriptura sacra, ms. Reg. et edit. Chiffl. In aliis editis codicibus male interpungebatur, quod studii facere. Idipsum idem, etc.
So Holy Scripture, the Royal manuscript and Chifflet's edition. In other printed editions it was wrongly punctuated: "quod studii facere. Idipsum idem", etc.
(printed under page 176)
(c) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 345 or 346
Vulgatam retinuimus lectionem quoadusque ex mss. codicibus major lux affulgeat. Mss. enim Reg. et Vien., quam sterili fide odiosam reminiscant quare nullo, etc. Nec placet Chiffletii correctio, quam sterili fide odiosam reminisci a te, avare, nullo reditu creditoris..... servatum.
We have kept the common reading until more light dawns from the manuscripts. For the Royal and Vienna manuscripts have "quam sterili fide odiosam reminiscant quare nullo", etc. Nor does Chifflet's correction please: "quam sterili fide odiosam reminisci a te, avare, nullo reditu creditoris..... servatum".
(printed under page 176)
(m) ‹anchor: emti sumus› · call in col 346
I Cor. VI, 20.
1 Corinthians 6:20.
(printed under page 176)
(n) ‹anchor: unus Deus› · call in col 346
Matth. XIX, 17.
Matthew 19:17.
Editors' notes (printed under page 176)
(d) ‹anchor: mundi arbiter› · call in col 346
Ita restituimus ex ms. codice Vien. et edit. Chiffl. postulante sensu. Alii, praecurrit.
So we have restored it from the Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition, as the sense requires. Others have "praecurrit".
(printed under page 176)
(e) ‹anchor: Dominum de› · call in col 346
Ms. Reg. et editi 5, bonis; utraque lectio recepta. Ea quam reposuimus ex ms. codice Vien. et edit. Chiffl. confirmatur ex sequentibus, et n. 6 et 7.
The Royal manuscript and five editions have "bonis"; both readings are accepted. The one we have restored from the Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition is confirmed by what follows, and by nos. 6 and 7.
(printed under page 176)
Scripture references (printed under page 177)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347
Psal. XV, 2.
Psalm 15:2.
(printed under page 177)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347
I Tim. II, 4.
1 Timothy 2:4.
(printed under page 177)
(c) ‹anchor: ex servo vocet› · call in col 347
Johan. XV, 15.
John 15:15.
(printed under page 177)
(d) ‹anchor: rape regna coelorum› · call in col 347
Matth. XI, 12.
Matthew 11:12.
(printed under page 177)
(e) ‹anchor: pauperes fecit› · call in col 347
Prov. XIV, 31.
Proverbs 14:31.
(printed under page 177)
(f) ‹anchor: egenum et pauperem› · call in col 347
Psal. XL, 2.
Psalm 40:2.
(printed under page 177)
(g) ‹anchor: refrigerio vitae affluebat› · call in col 347
Luc. XVI, 24.
Luke 16:24.
(printed under page 177)
(h) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347 or 348
Johan. VII, 38.
John 7:38 (the verse numeral is unclear on the scan).
(printed under page 177)
(i) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347 or 348
Matth. XXV, 21; Luc. XIX, 17.
Matthew 25:21; Luke 19:17.
(printed under page 177)
(j) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347 or 348
Exod. XXIII, 15.
Exodus 23:15.
(printed under page 177)
(k) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347 or 348
I Tim. VI, 18.
1 Timothy 6:18 (the chapter numeral is unclear on the scan).
(printed under page 177)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 347
Sic emendavimus ex mss. Reg. et Vien. et edit. Chiffl. Alii codd., largius.
So we have corrected it from the Royal and Vienna manuscripts and Chifflet's edition. Other manuscripts have "largius".
(printed under page 177)
(b) ‹anchor: non mendicus› · call in col 347
Ms. Reg., Eleazar. Ita et apud Prudentium Cathemerin. hymn. 10, v. 154. Eleazar in mss. codicibus legi asserit N. Heinsius in notis, indeclinabile nomen, pro Lazarus de quo Lucas in Evangelio c. XVI, v. 19 et seqq. Vide quae diximus de hac voce ad epist. 13 ad Pammach., num. 17.
The Royal manuscript has "Eleazar". So too in Prudentius, Cathemerinon, hymn 10, line 154. N. Heinsius, in his notes, asserts that "Eleazar" is read in the manuscripts, an indeclinable name, for the Lazarus of whom Luke speaks in his Gospel, ch. 16, v. 19 and following. See what we have said of this word at Letter 13, to Pammachius, no. 17.
(printed under page 177)
(l) ‹anchor: perum Deum› · call in col 348
Psal. LXVII, 6.
Psalm 67:6.
(printed under page 177)
(m) ‹anchor: dilectio proximi› · call in col 348
Psal. X, 6; Rom. XIII, 10; Luc. X, 36.
Psalm 10:6; Romans 13:10; Luke 10:36.
(printed under page 177)
(n) ‹anchor: Deo cura sit› · call in col 348
I Cor. X, 33.
1 Corinthians 10:33.
(printed under page 177)
(o) ‹anchor: liberabit eum Dominus› · call in col 348
Tob. IV, 11; Psal. XL, 2.
Tobit 4:11; Psalm 40:2.
(printed under page 177)
(p) ‹anchor: fructum ... afferentem› · call in col 348
Matth. XIII, 8.
Matthew 13:8.
Editors' notes (printed under page 177)
(c) ‹anchor: creditor› · call in col 348
Ms. Vien. et edit. Chiffl., penset. Ms. Reg. cum editis quatuor, creditos pensitet.
The Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition have "penset"; the Royal manuscript, with four editions, "creditos pensitet".
(printed under page 177)
Scripture references (printed under page 178)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349
I Pet. V, 8.
1 Peter 5:8.
(printed under page 178)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349
Prov. XIV, 12, et XVI, 25.
Proverbs 14:12 and 16:25.
(printed under page 178)
(c) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349
Psal. XVI, 12.
Psalm 16:12.
(printed under page 178)
(d) ‹anchor: spinis et tribulis› · call in col 349
Gen. III, 18.
Genesis 3:18.
(printed under page 178)
(e) ‹anchor: remedium salutis› · call in col 349
Eccli. XXXVIII, 1.
Ecclesiasticus (Sirach) 38:1.
(printed under page 178)
(f) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349 or 350
Matth. XXIV, 46.
Matthew 24:46.
(printed under page 178)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349
Ms. Vien. codex et edit. Chiffl., saepe se gressibus. Melior et verior vulgata lectio quam retinemus. Vide ea quae praecesserunt et subsequuntur.
The Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition have "saepe se gressibus". The common reading, which we keep, is better and truer. See what went before and what follows.
(printed under page 178)
(b) ‹anchor: cupiditatum faces› · call in col 349
Ms. Reg. et edit. Chiffl., accedunt, mendose, ut nobis videtur.
The Royal manuscript and Chifflet's edition have "accedunt", wrongly, as it seems to us.
(printed under page 178)
(c) ‹anchor: Tu taces, et› · call in col 349
Haec duo verba absunt a ms. codice Vien. et edit. Chifflet.
These two words are missing from the Vienna manuscript and Chifflet's edition.
(printed under page 178)
(d) ‹anchor: not visible› · call in col 349 or 350
Ita editi quatuor cum ms. Vatic. Optima lectio. At quo sensu mss. Reg. et Vien. et edit. Chiffl., et divitiae tuae illius opes paupertati divites sunt? Ms. Reg., paupertatis
So four editions, with the Vatican manuscript. It is the best reading. But in what sense do the Royal and Vienna manuscripts and Chifflet's edition read "et divitiae tuae illius opes paupertati divites sunt"? The Royal manuscript has "paupertatis".
(printed under page 178)