PL 7 · cols. 285–290
Venantius Honorius Clementianus Fortunatus, Ad Felicem episcopum de Pascha
Editors' preface
Migne Reading Room
PL 7 · cols. 285–290
Editors' preface
<!-- The page foot holds two blocks: the LECTIONES VARIANTES closing the preceding poem (lines 22–77), and the first ANNOTATIO on the Fortunatus poem. Both are set below in print order. --> (LV 1) ‹anchor: Semper agens› · variant to v. 22 of the preceding poem, block under cols 285-286 V. 22. Semper agens, etc. Al. Egens.
Line 22: "Semper agens" (ever acting), etc. Another reading: "Egens" (needy).
(LV 2) ‹anchor: Fige› · variant to v. 35 of the preceding poem V. 35. Fige. Al. Finge.
Line 35: "Fige" (fix). Another reading: "Finge" (form).
(LV 3) ‹anchor: Suffunde› · variant to v. 52 of the preceding poem V. 52. Suffunde. Al. Perfunde.
Line 52: "Suffunde" (pour beneath, suffuse). Another reading: "Perfunde" (pour over, drench).
(LV 4) ‹anchor: Et me nonnunquam› · variant to v. 53 of the preceding poem V. 53. Et me nonnunquam. Al. Et me nunquam non.
Line 53: "Et me nonnunquam" (and me sometimes). Another reading: "Et me nunquam non" (and me never not, i.e. always).
(LV 5) ‹anchor: Hæc monimenta› · variant to vv. 58 and 64 of the preceding poem V. 58 et 64. Hæc monimenta. Al. Hæc monumenta.
Lines 58 and 64: "Hæc monimenta" (these memorials). Another reading: "Hæc monumenta" (the same word in its other spelling).
(LV 6) ‹anchor: Moribus extollent sacris› · variant to v. 72 of the preceding poem V. 72. Moribus extollent sacris. Al. Moribus expolient sacris.
Line 72: "Moribus extollent sacris" (they will exalt with holy ways). Another reading: "Moribus expolient sacris" (they will polish with holy ways).
(LV 7) ‹anchor: Gratia magna tibi› · variant to v. 77 of the preceding poem V. 77. Gratia magna tibi. Al. Gratia magna Dei.
Line 77: "Gratia magna tibi" (great grace to you). Another reading: "Gratia magna Dei" (the great grace of God).
(Annot. 1) ‹anchor: Venantii… ad Felicem episcopum (title)› · note-mark at the title, block runs from col 285 into col 286 Venantii... ad felicem episcopum. In carminibus Resurrectionis, quia aperte invenitur cujus illa essent, mutata est tota inscriptio, et ea adscripta est, quæ est in illis opusculis, Venantii Honorii, etc., quæ sunt in bibliotheca Vaticana, ex quibus multa in libris impressis emendantur; multa tamen relicta sunt, quia melior visa est lectio vulgaris, quam illa codicis Vaticani. Est enim ille codex valde corruptus; tamen is est, qui eum juvare possit, qui eo cum judicio utatur. Et sane sic faciendum est eis, qui hanc curam emendandi veterum auctorum libros suscipiunt, ut sæpe ex pluribus malis codicibus unicum optimum efficiant. THOMASIUS.
"Venantius… to Felix the bishop." In the poems on the Resurrection, since it is plainly found whose they were, the whole heading has been changed, and the one has been set to them that stands in those little works, "of Venantius Honorius, etc.", which are in the Vatican Library; from them many things in the printed books are corrected, yet many have been left, because the common reading seemed better than that of the Vatican manuscript. For that manuscript is badly corrupt; yet it is one that can help whoever uses it with judgement. And indeed those who take on this task of correcting the books of the ancient authors must do just this: often make one excellent copy out of several bad manuscripts. THOMASIUS.
(printed under page 142)
<!-- The page foot holds the LECTIONES VARIANTES (by line number, left block col 287, right block col 288) and the ANNOTATIONES (by line number, running from col 287 into col 288). --> (LV 1) ‹anchor: Acer nux› · variant to v. 23, col 287 V. 23. Acer nux. Alii legunt, acernus.
Line 23: "Acer nux" (maple, nut). Others read "acernus" (of maple).
(LV 2) ‹anchor: Cuncta› · variant to v. 42, col 287 V. 42. Cuncta. Al. Puncta.
Line 42: "Cuncta" (all things). Another reading: "Puncta" (points, moments).
(LV 3) ‹anchor: Has inter› · variant to v. 46, col 287 V. 46. Has inter, etc. Aliter: Has inter minimus passer amore cano.
Line 46: "Has inter", etc. Otherwise: "Among these I, a tiny sparrow, sing for love."
(LV 4) ‹anchor: Patris ore› · variant to v. 50, col 287 V. 50. Patris ore. Al. Penetrare.
Line 50: "Patris ore" (by the Father's mouth). Another reading: "Penetrare" (to penetrate).
(LV 5) ‹anchor: Funeris› · variant to v. 59, col 287 V. 59. Funeris, etc. Aliter: Funeris exequias pateris vitæ auctor et orbis.
Line 59: "Funeris", etc. Otherwise: "The rites of death you suffer, author of life and of the world."
(LV 6) ‹anchor: Intra› · variant to v. 60, col 287 V. 60. Intra. Al. Intras.
Line 60: "Intra" (within). Another reading: "Intras" (you enter).
(LV 7) ‹anchor: Tristia cessarunt› · variant to v. 61, col 287 V. 61. Tristia cessarunt. Al. Tristia cesserunt.
Line 61: "Tristia cessarunt" (sorrows have ceased). Another reading: "Tristia cesserunt" (sorrows have given way).
(LV 8) ‹anchor: Æternæ› · variant to v. 64, col 288 V. 64. Æternæ. Al. Et terræ.
Line 64: "Æternæ" (eternal). Another reading: "Et terræ" (and of the earth).
(LV 9) ‹anchor: Sollicitam› · variant to v. 65, col 288 V. 65. Sollicitam. Al. Pollicitam.
Line 65: "Sollicitam" (anxious). Another reading: "Pollicitam" (promised).
(LV 10) ‹anchor: Non› · variant to v. 68, col 288 V. 68. Non. Al. Nec. Al. Neu.
Line 68: "Non" (not). Another reading: "Nec" (nor). Another: "Neu" (nor, lest).
(LV 11) ‹anchor: Raperet› · variant to v. 80, col 288 V. 80. Raperet. Al. Rapuit.
Line 80: "Raperet" (should seize). Another reading: "Rapuit" (seized).
(LV 12) ‹anchor: Abis› · variant to v. 82, col 288 V. 82. Abis. Al. Adit.
Line 82: "Abis" (you go away). Another reading: "Adit" (he approaches).
(LV 13) ‹anchor: Iste› · variant to v. 87, col 288 V. 87. Iste. Al. In te.
Line 87: "Iste" (this one). Another reading: "In te" (in you).
(LV 14) ‹anchor: Trophæi› · variant to v. 89, col 288 V. 89. Trophæi. Al. Triumphi.
Line 89: "Trophæi" (of the trophy). Another reading: "Triumphi" (of the triumph).
(LV 15) ‹anchor: Concors› · variant to v. 95, col 288 V. 95. Concors. Al. Consors.
Line 95: "Concors" (of one heart). Another reading: "Consors" (sharer, partner).
(Annot. 1) ‹anchor: Salve festa dies (v. 39)› · note to v. 39, runs from col 287 into col 288 (continues) Vers. 39. Salve festa dies, toto venerabilis ævo, Qua Deus infernum vicit et astra tenet. Auctoritate codicis Vaticani mutatus est versus, ut esset post viginti disticha, quo sane in loco esse debet. Nam ante nihil de Passione vel Resurrectione Christi dicitur: sed ver ipsum ex multis propriis naturæ suæ bonis commendatur. Postquam vero facta est mentio Resurrectionis, recte illud additur: Salve festa dies, etc., cui disticho recte etiam illud continenter adjungitur Nobilitas anni, mensum, lux alma dierum, Horarum splendor, stridula puncta favent. Nobilitas enim legendum est ex codice Vaticano, ut laus aliqua illi diei, quem laudare vult, attribuatur; cum ex mobilitate, ut erat ante, nulla laus ad diem aliquem accedere possit, quia hoc est omnibus (continues)
Line 39: "Hail, festal day, to be revered through all the age, on which God conquered hell and holds the stars." On the authority of the Vatican manuscript the line has been moved so as to stand after twenty couplets, which is surely where it ought to be. For before that nothing is said of Christ's Passion or Resurrection: the spring itself is commended for the many goods proper to its nature. But once the Resurrection has been mentioned, there is rightly added "Hail, festal day", etc., and to that couplet is rightly joined, straight on, this one too: "Glory of the year, of the months, kindly light of the days, splendour of the hours, the shrill moments applaud." For "Nobilitas" (glory) is to be read from the Vatican manuscript, so that some praise may be given to the day he means to praise; whereas from "mobilitas" (changeableness), as it stood before, no praise could accrue to any day, since this is common to all (continues)
(printed under page 143)
<!-- This page's text is no longer the De Pascha: it is Symposius's Aenigmata (prologue and riddles 1–9), and the foot holds the VARIORUM NOTÆ to that work. The continuation of page 143's annotation on v. 39 does not appear in this page foot. --> (Var. 1) ‹anchor: Cœlii Symposii (title)› · note-mark at the title, runs from col 289 into col 290 Cœlii Symphosii. Primus, quod sciam, Christophorus Heumannus hos versus Lactantio tribuit, quorum quidem meminit S. Hieronymus. Hi prius editi fuerant sub nomine Cœlii Firmiani Symposii Poetæ a Nicolao Caussino e Societ. Jesu, atque adjecti Hieroglyphicis Hori Apollinis. Jam ab anno 1533, publici juris fecerat hæc ænigmata sub nomine Symphosii poetæ Joachimus Perionius. Alii vero non Symphosium, sed Symposium vocarunt. Ansam vero arripuit haud dubie Heumannus Lactantio tribuendi hæc ænigmata, quod in quibusdam editionibus Cœlii Firmiani titulum præferant; et nomen Poetæ qui Symposius dicebatur putavit Symposium, id est, convivium inscribendum esse. Sic etiam recentiores quidam ediderunt Sermones convivales. Attamen eruditi omnes, ac præsertim Joan. Albert. Fabricius, non descenderunt in Heumanni sententiam.
"Of Cælius Symphosius." The first, so far as I know, to attribute these verses to Lactantius was Christoph Heumann, verses which St Jerome does indeed mention. They had earlier been published under the name of "Cælius Firmianus Symposius, Poet" by Nicolas Caussin of the Society of Jesus, appended to the Hieroglyphics of Horapollo. As early as 1533 Joachim Périon had made these riddles public under the name of "Symphosius the poet". Others, however, called him not Symphosius but Symposius. Heumann no doubt seized his handle for attributing these riddles to Lactantius from the fact that in some editions they bear the title "of Cælius Firmianus"; and he thought that the name of the poet who was called Symposius should be written "Symposium", that is, "banquet". So too certain more recent editors have published them as "Table Talk". Yet all the learned, and above all Johann Albert Fabricius, have not come round to Heumann's opinion.
(Var. 2) ‹anchor: Dulcia mensæ (prologue, v. 5)› · note to the prologue, col 290 Dulcia mensæ. Hinc patet hos versus nihil aliud esse, quam sermones convivales; proindeque Symposium nomen esse operis, non poetæ.
"Sweet [cups] of the table." Hence it is plain that these verses are nothing other than table talk, and therefore that "Symposium" is the name of the work, not of the poet.
(printed under page 144)
commune. Legendum quoque est, stridula puncta in secundo versu, ut omnia ad diem referantur. Aliqua alia in his carminibus mutantur, quae tamen meliora facta sunt: quod quivis hunc librum cum aliis conferens intelligere poterit. THOMASIUS.
… common. One should also read stridula puncta in the second verse, so that everything may be referred to the day. Some other things in these poems are altered, which have nevertheless been made better: which anyone comparing this book with others will be able to understand. THOMASIUS.
Vers. 101. Mitibus. Hi sequentes versus additi sunt ex codice Vaticano a Thomasio, cujus haec verba sunt. In hoc poemate ex illo codice addidi decem versus, qui optime cum reipsa conveniunt, et declarant cur illa carmina ad Felicem Episcopum Venantius scripserit, qui sane Felix nullus est Romanorum Pontificum, sed fuit aliquis ex primis illis Saxonum Episcopis. Nam Saxones, cum a Carolo Magno post bellum triginta annorum et amplius victi essent, religionem Christianam susceperunt: ex Romanis vero Pontificibus ultimus qui nomen hoc Felicis habuit fuit Felix IV, qui multo ante Carolum Magnum vixit. Illos verò decem versus propterea judicavi addendos, quia optime cum re de qua agitur conveniunt, et quia in fine poematis additus erat numerus versuum cx, ita ut omnino decem ad explendum numerum deessent.
Verse 101. Mitibus ("With gentle"). These following verses were added from a Vatican codex by Thomasius, whose words are these: "In this poem I have added from that codex ten verses, which agree excellently with the matter itself, and make clear why Venantius wrote those poems to Bishop Felix; which Felix is certainly none of the Roman Pontiffs, but was one of those first bishops of the Saxons. For the Saxons, when they had been conquered by Charlemagne after a war of thirty years and more, accepted the Christian religion; whereas of the Roman Pontiffs the last who bore this name of Felix was Felix IV, who lived long before Charlemagne. I judged those ten verses ought to be added for this reason, that they agree excellently with the matter in hand, and that at the end of the poem the number of verses had been added as cx, so that exactly ten were lacking to fill up the number."
<!-- note: Set the upper VARIORUM NOTAE block at the page foot, which comes under the last lines of Fortunatus's poem (vv. 101–110) and above the rule and the title of Coelius Symphosius's Aenigmata. It opens mid-sentence with "commune.", the tail of the Annotatio on v. 39 run over from page 143 (col. 287/288), and ends with the note on v. 101, which is complete in this column. Two paragraphs. The column body holds no other editors' prose: the "Haec quoque Symphosius" lines are the author's verse prologue, and the lower VARIORUM NOTAE block (on Symphosius) was left alone. PLACEMENT NOT DONE: I was told to read nothing else, so I could not open n289 or n287 to edit them (an existing file can't be overwritten without being read first). Still to do: copy these two paragraphs into n289 under Footnotes, above the Symposius notes, and add a pointer line in n287 after the Annotatio marked "continues". -->