Migne Reading Room

PL 38 · cols. 1445–1448

Augustine, Sermones 323-328 (Classis III, de Sanctis)

Sermons CCCXXIII–CCCXXV

PL 38:1445
SERMO CCCXXIII Habitus post libellum de sancto Stephano.
Sermon 323. Delivered after the booklet on Saint Stephen.
CAPUT PRIMUM. — 1. Parentum imprecationes in filios, quam reformidandae. Misericordia quidem Dei, fratres, sicut credendum est, omnes isti fratres, quos una Dei ira materna plaga percussit, ad hujus de quo gaudemus, quandoque perventuri sunt sanitatem. Verumtamen discant filii obsequi, timeant parentes irasci. Scriptum est, Benedictio patris firmat domum filiorum: maledictio matris eradicat fundamenta (Eccli. III, 11). Modo isti per terras in fundamentis patriae suae non sunt: praebent ubique spectaculum, proponunt suum supplicium; praebent oculis miseriam suam, terrent superbiam alienam. Discite filii, quod dicit Scriptura, reddere honorem parentibus debitum. Sed et vos, parentes, quando offendimini, parentes vos esse recordamini. Oravit mater contra filios, exaudita est; quia Deus vere justus est, quia vere injuriam passa fuerat. Unus ipsorum et verba contumeliosa et manus injecerat; et caeteri matris injuriam patienter tulerunt, nec unum pro ea verbum contra fratrem responderunt. Justus Deus qui audivit precantem, audivit dolentem. Sed quid illa misera? Nonne unde citius exaudita, inde plus punita? Discite hoc petere a Deo, ubi non timeatis exaudiri.
Chapter I. — 1. The imprecations of parents against their children, how much they are to be dreaded. By the mercy of God indeed, brethren, as is to be believed, all these brothers, whom the wrath of God struck together with a mother's blow, will at some time attain to the health of this one over whom we rejoice. Nevertheless let children learn to obey, let parents fear to be angry. It is written, The blessing of the father establishes the house of the children: the curse of the mother uproots the foundations (Ecclus. 3:11). Now these men are throughout the lands, not in the foundations of their native country: they present a spectacle everywhere, they display their punishment; they present their misery to the eyes, they terrify the pride of others. Learn, children, as Scripture says, to render the honour due to parents. But you too, parents, when you are offended, remember that you are parents. The mother prayed against her sons, she was heard; because God is truly just, because she had truly suffered injury. One of them had both [used] insulting words and laid hands [on her]; and the rest bore their mother's injury patiently, and did not answer one word on her behalf against their brother. The just God Who heard her praying heard her grieving. But what of that wretched woman? Was she not punished the more by the very thing in which she was heard the more quickly? Learn to ask this of God, where you need not fear to be heard.
CAPUT II. — 2. Sanitas duobus fratribus non impetrata Anconae, ut iis Hippone concederetur. Memoria Stephani qua occasione apud Anconam ante corporis ejus detectionem exstructa. Nos autem, fratres, satagamus Domino Deo nostro gratias referre pro illo qui sanatus est; et pro illa quae adhuc tenetur, preces fundamus. Benedicamus Deum, quia dignos nos habuit, ut hoc videremus. Quid enim sumus, quia ego apparui istis nesciens? Illi enim me videbant, et ego nesciebam: et admonebantur ut ad istam civitatem venirent. Quis sum ego? Homo sum unus de multis, non de magnis. Et vere, ut audiat Charitas vestra, multum miror, et gaudeo nobis esse concessum: quoniam iste homo nec Anconae curari potuit; imo potuit, sed propter nos factum non est, quia facillime fieri potuit. Sciunt enim multi quanta miracula per beatissimum martyrem Stephanum in ista civitate fiant. Et audite quod miremini: memoria ejus antiqua ibi erat, et ipsa est ibi. Sed fortasse dicis: Corpus ejus nondum apparuerat, memoria ibi unde erat? Latet quidem causa: sed quid ad nos fama pertulerit, non tacebo Charitati vestrae. Quando lapidabatur sanctus Stephanus, aliqui etiam innocentes, et maxime de iis qui jam in Christum crediderant, circumstabant: dicitur lapis venisse in cubitum, et excussus inde venisse ante quemdam religiosum. Tulit illum, et servavit. Homo erat de navigantibus, sors navigationis attulit illum ad littus Anconae, et revelatum est illi ibi debere reponi lapidem illum. Ille obedivit revelationi,
Chapter II. — 2. Health not obtained for the two brothers at Ancona, so that it might be granted them at Hippo. On what occasion the shrine of Stephen at Ancona was built before the discovery of his body. But let us, brethren, take pains to render thanks to the Lord our God for that man who has been healed; and for that woman who is still held fast, let us pour out prayers. Let us bless God, that He has held us worthy to see this. For what are we, that I appeared to these people without knowing it? For they saw me, and I did not know it: and they were admonished to come to this city. Who am I? I am a man, one of many, not one of the great. And truly, that your Charity may hear, I greatly wonder, and rejoice that it has been granted to us: since this man could not be cured even at Ancona; nay, he could, but for our sake it was not done, since it could very easily have been done. For many know how many miracles take place through the most blessed martyr Stephen in this city. And hear something to wonder at: his shrine was there of old, and it is there still. But perhaps you say: His body had not yet appeared; whence was there a shrine there? The cause indeed is hidden: but what report has brought to us, I will not keep silent from your Charity. When Saint Stephen was being stoned, some innocent people also, and especially some of those who had already believed in Christ, were standing round: a stone is said to have struck him on the elbow, and, glancing off from there, to have come before a certain devout man. He took it up and kept it. He was a man from among the seafarers; the lot of his voyage brought him to the shore of Ancona, and it was revealed to him that that stone ought to be laid up there. He obeyed the revelation,
Editors' notes and page, col. 1445

Footnotes

(b) ‹anchor: not visible in the page-foot image› · call in col 1445

Alias, de Diversis 32.

Formerly [numbered] On Various Subjects 32.

(printed under page 729)

Page

  • running head: 1445 SERMO CCCXXIV. (right-hand part cut off at image edge)
  • marginal letters: (none)
  • old-edition numerals: (none)
  • other: the column opens with the end of the previous work (another unit); not set here: the unit begins at SERMO CCCXXIII
  • other: footnote (a) on this page (Vid. lib. 22 de Civitate Dei, cap. 8) is called at the end of the preceding sermon, above SERMO CCCXXIII (another unit); not set here (removed by QA Q1)
PL 38:1446
et fecit quod jussum est : ex illo coepit esse ibi memoria sancti Stephani, et rumor erat quia brachium sancti Stephani ibi est, nescientibus hominibus quid contigisset. Verum autem intelligitur propterea ibi fuisse revelatum, ut ibi poneret lapidem qui de cubito Martyris excussus est, quia graece cubitum ἀγκών dicitur. Sed qui sciunt quae ibi miracula fiant, ipsi nos doceant. Non ibi coeperunt fieri ista miracula, nisi posteaquam corpus sancti Stephani apparuit. Ecce ibi non est curatus iste juvenis, ut nostris oculis servaretur.
and he did what had been commanded: from that time there began to be a memorial of Saint Stephen there, and the rumour was that the arm of Saint Stephen is there, since people did not know what had happened. But the truth is understood to be that it was revealed there for this reason, that he might place there the stone which had been struck off the Martyr's elbow, because in Greek an elbow is called ankōn. But let those who know what miracles happen there teach us themselves. These miracles did not begin to happen there until after the body of Saint Stephen had appeared. See, this young man was not cured there, so that he might be kept for our eyes.
3. De miraculis apud Uzalim factis. Apud Uzalim ubi est episcopus frater meus Evodius, quanta miracula ibi fiant quaerite, et invenietis. Praetermissis autem aliis, indico vobis unum quod ibi factum est, ut videatis quanta sit ibi praesentia majestatis.
3. On the miracles done at Uzalis. At Uzalis, where my brother Evodius is bishop, inquire how great are the miracles that happen there, and you will find out. But passing over the others, I point out to you one which was done there, so that you may see how great the presence of majesty is there.
CAPUT III. — Mulier quaedam subito aegrotum filium, cui succurrere festinando non potuit, in gremio suo catechumenum amisit : quae clamans, Mortuus est, inquit, filius meus catechumenus.
Chapter III. — A certain woman lost in her lap, while still a catechumen, her son who had suddenly fallen ill, whom she had not been able to help in spite of her haste; and crying out she said, My son has died a catechumen.
4. Populi clamor ex subita curatione puellae exortus. Et cum haec diceret Augustinus, populus de memoria sancti Stephani clamare coepit, Deo gratias! Christo laudes! In quo continuo clamore, puella quae curata est ad absidam perducta est. Qua visa, populus cum gaudio et fletu, nullis interpositis sermonibus, sed solo strepitu interposito, aliquandiu clamorem protraxit : et silentio facto, Augustinus episcopus dixit, Scriptum est in Psalmo, Dixi, Proloquar adversum me delictum meum Domino Deo meo, et tu dimisisti impietatem cordis mei (Psal. XXXI, 5). Dixi, Proloquar : nondum prolocutus sum : Dixi, Proloquar, et tu dimisisti. Commendavi istam miseram, imo ex misera, commendavi eam vestris orationibus. Disposuimus orare, et exauditi sumus. Sit gaudium nostrum actio gratiarum. Citius exaudita est mater Ecclesia, quam in perniciem maledicta mater illa. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.
4. The shout of the people arising from the sudden cure of a girl. And while Augustine was saying these things, the people at the memorial of Saint Stephen began to cry out, Thanks be to God! Praise to Christ! Amid this continuous shouting the girl who had been cured was led to the apse. When she was seen, the people with joy and weeping, with no words put in between but only the noise put in between, prolonged their shouting for some while; and when silence had been made, Augustine the bishop said, It is written in the Psalm, I said, I will declare against myself my offence to the Lord my God, and Thou hast forgiven the impiety of my heart (Ps. 31:5). I said, I will declare: I have not yet declared: I said, I will declare, and Thou hast forgiven. I commended this wretched woman, or rather her who was once wretched, I commended her to your prayers. We purposed to pray, and we have been heard. Let our joy be thanksgiving. Mother Church was heard more quickly than that mother cursing [her children] to their ruin. Turning to the Lord, etc.
SERMO CCCXXIV. Quo Augustinus complet partem sermonis mox praecedentis miraculo interrupti.
Sermon 324. In which Augustine completes the part of the immediately preceding sermon that was interrupted by a miracle.
Miraculum apud Uzalim factum. Parvulo ante baptismum ext⟨i⟩ncto vita reddita, ut sacramenta perciperet. Debet a nobis hesternus sermo compleri, qui majori interruptus est gaudio. Statueram enim et coeperam loqui Charitati vestrae, quare mihi videntur isti fratres divina auctoritate ad hanc civitatem esse directi, ut hic in eis diu optata et exspectata sanitas impleretur. Et hoc volens dicere, prius commendare coeperam Charitati vestrae loca sancta, in quibus non sunt sanati, et ad nos inde sunt directi. Et dixi de Ancona civitate Italiae : coeperam de Uzali civitate dicere, quae est in Africa (episcopum habet fratrem meum, quem nostis, Evodium) ; quia et ad illam civitatem eos venire, fama ejusdem martyris et operum ejus compulisset. Non est illic datum quod dari potuit, ut hic daretur ubi dari debuit. Cum autem opera divina per sanctum Martyrem commemorare breviter
A miracle done at Uzalis. Life restored to a little child who had died before baptism, so that he might receive the sacraments. Yesterday's sermon ought to be completed by us, which was interrupted by a greater joy. For I had determined, and had begun, to tell Your Charity why it seems to me that these brothers were directed by divine authority to this city, so that here in them the long-desired and long-awaited health might be fulfilled. And wishing to say this, I had first begun to commend to Your Charity the holy places in which they were not healed and from which they were directed to us. And I spoke of Ancona, a city of Italy; I had begun to speak of Uzalis, a city which is in Africa (it has as its bishop my brother Evodius, whom you know); because the fame of the same martyr and of his works had driven them to come to that city too. What could have been given there was not given, so that it might be given here, where it ought to be given. But when to recount briefly the divine works through the holy Martyr
Editors' notes and page, col. 1446

Footnotes

(a) ‹anchor: SERMO CCCXXIV› · call in col 1446

Alias, de Diversis 33.

Formerly [numbered] On Various Subjects 33.

(printed under page 729)

Page

  • running head: [SERM]O CCCXXIV. (cut off at left edge) 1446
  • marginal letters: (none)
  • old-edition numerals: (none)
PL 38:1447
vellem, omissis caeteris, unum institueram dicere: quod cum dico, restituta illi puellae sanitate, subito laetitiae tumultus exortus est, et nos aliter compulit ⟨f⟩inire sermonem. Ergo tale ibi miraculum scimus factum inter multa alia, quae commemorari utique cuncta non possunt. Mulier quaedam amisit in gremio aegrotantem filium catechumenum infantem lactentem. Quae cum vidisset amissum et irreparabiliter perditum, coepit eum magis flere fideliter, quam mater. Non enim filii sui desiderabat vitam, nisi in futuro saeculo, et hanc sibi ablatam et perisse plangebat. Impleta affectu fiduciae tulit illum mortuum, et cucurrit ad memoriam beati martyris Stephani, et coepit ab illo exigere filium, et dicere: Sancte martyr, vides nullum mihi remansisse solatium. Non enim possum dicere filium praecessisse, quem nosti periisse: tu enim vides quare plangam. Redde filium meum, ut habeam eum ante conspectum coronatoris tui. Haec et talia cum precaretur, lacrymis quodam modo non petentibus, sed ut dixi, exigentibus, revixit filius ejus. Et quia dixerat, Nosti quare illum quaeram: ostendere voluit etiam Deus verum animum ipsius. Continuo tulit illum ad presbyteros, baptizatus est, sanctificatus est, unctus est, imposita est ei manus, completis omnibus sacramentis, assumptus est. Illa autem tali eum cum vultu deduxit, tanquam non deduceret ad requiem sepulcri, sed ad sinum martyris Stephani. Probatum est cor fidele mulieris. Ubi ergo tale miraculum fecit Deus per Martyrem suum, non potuit ibi istos curare? Et tamen huc nobis directi sunt. Conversi ad Dominum, etc.
I wished, setting aside the rest, I had resolved to say one thing: and as I was saying it, health having been restored to that girl, suddenly an uproar of joy broke out, and compelled us to end the sermon otherwise. So we know that such a miracle was done there among many others, which certainly cannot all be recounted. A certain woman lost in her lap her sick son, a catechumen, an infant still at the breast. When she saw him lost and irreparably gone, she began to weep for him more faithfully than as a mother. For she did not desire her son's life except in the world to come, and she lamented that this had been taken from her and had perished. Filled with an affection of trust, she took him up dead, and ran to the memorial of the blessed martyr Stephen, and began to demand her son from him, and to say: Holy martyr, you see that no consolation has remained to me. For I cannot say that my son has gone before, whom you know to have perished: for you see why I lament. Give back my son, that I may have him before the sight of the One who crowned you. While she prayed these and such things, with tears in a certain manner not asking but, as I said, demanding, her son came back to life. And because she had said, You know why I seek him, God wished also to show her true mind. At once she took him to the presbyters; he was baptized, he was sanctified, he was anointed, the hand was laid upon him, and with all the sacraments completed, he was taken up. And she escorted him with such a countenance as though she were escorting him not to the rest of the tomb but to the bosom of the martyr Stephen. The faithful heart of the woman was proved. Where, then, God worked such a miracle through His Martyr, could He not have cured these people there? And yet they have been directed here to us. Turning to the Lord, etc.
SERMO CCCXXV. In Natali viginti Martyrum.
Sermon 325. On the Birthday of the Twenty Martyrs.
1. Solemnitates martyrum cur institutae. Die solemni sanctorum Martyrum debitus sermo reddendus est. De gloria martyrum locuturos, breviter justam causam martyrum locuturos, adjuvent nos orationes martyrum. Hoc enim per istas solemnitates commemorari debet Sanctitas vestra, primum ne arbitremur aliquid nos conferre martyribus, quia eorum dies solemnissimos celebramus. Illi nostris festivitatibus non egent, quia in coelis cum Angelis gaudent: congaudent autem nobis, non si honoremus eos, sed si imitemur eos. Quanquam et quod honoramus, nobis prodest, non illis. Sed honorare, et non imitari, nihil est aliud quam mendaciter adulari. Ad hoc ergo istae festivitates in Ecclesia constitutae sunt Christi, ut per eas congregatio membrorum Christi admoneatur imitari martyres Christi. Haec est omnino hujus festivitatis utilitas, alia non est. Si
1. Why the solemnities of the martyrs were instituted. On the solemn day of the holy Martyrs a sermon is owed and must be rendered. As we are about to speak of the glory of the martyrs, about to speak briefly of the just cause of the martyrs, may the prayers of the martyrs help us. For by these solemnities Your Holiness ought to be reminded of this: first, that we should not think that we confer anything on the martyrs because we celebrate their most solemn days. They have no need of our festivities, because they rejoice in heaven with the Angels: but they rejoice together with us, not if we honour them, but if we imitate them. Although even the fact that we honour them profits us, not them. But to honour and not to imitate is nothing else than to flatter falsely. For this purpose, then, these festivities were established in the Church of Christ, that through them the congregation of the members of Christ might be admonished to imitate the martyrs of Christ. This is altogether the usefulness of this festivity; there is no other. If
Editors' notes and page, col. 1447

Footnotes

(*) ‹anchor: SERMO CCCXXV› · call in col 1447 Collatus ad m. r. rm. t. v. et ad Sirm.

Collated against the manuscripts m., r., rm., t., v. and against Sirmond['s edition].

(printed under page 730)

(a) ‹anchor: not visible in the page-foot image› · call in col 1447

Forte, materne.

Perhaps [read] "materne" ("in a mother's way").

(printed under page 730)

(b) ‹anchor: SERMO CCCXXV› · call in col 1447

Alias, inter Sirmondianos 30.

Formerly [numbered] 30 among Sirmond's sermons.

(printed under page 730)

(c) ‹anchor: viginti Martyrum› · call in col 1447

Hos Baronius eosdem censet cum Martyribus viginti, qui apud Tarsum Ciliciæ passi sub Diocletiano leguntur die 6 junii. Diversos esse, certius videri sibi monet Sirmondus, cujus nos opinioni facilius accedimus. Horum martyrum memoriam Hippone celeberrimam fuisse docet Augustinus, illustre quod in ea contigerat miraculum commemorans in libro 22 de Civitate Dei, cap. 8. Ad istam basilicam dictus fuit Sermo 148. De iisdem viginti Martyribus forte est sermo subsequens.

Baronius judges these to be the same as the twenty Martyrs who are read [in the martyrology] to have suffered at Tarsus in Cilicia under Diocletian on 6 June. Sirmond notes that it seems more certain to him that they are different, and we more readily accept his opinion. Augustine shows that the shrine of these martyrs at Hippo was very much frequented, when he records a famous miracle that had occurred in it, in book 22 of The City of God, chapter 8. Sermon 148 was preached at that basilica. The sermon that follows is perhaps on the same twenty Martyrs.

(printed under page 730)

Page

  • running head: 1447 S. AUGUSTINI EPIS[COPI] (cut off at image edge)
  • marginal letters: (none)
  • old-edition numerals: (none)
PL 38:1448
enim nobis proponatur imitandus Deus, respondet humana fragilitas, multum esse ad se imitari eum, cui non potest comparari. Si deinde ipsius Domini nostri Jesu Christi ad imitationem nobis proponatur exemplum, qui propterea cum Deus esset, mortali carne vestitus est, ut hominibus mortalem carnem gerentibus insinuaret praeceptum, et demonstraret exemplum; de quo etiam scriptum est, Christus pro nobis passus est, relinquens nobis exemplum, ut sequamur vestigia ejus (I Petr. II, 21): tamen et hic adhuc respondet humana fragilitas, Quid simile ego et Christus? Ille etsi caro, tamen Verbum caro. Verbum enim caro factum, ut habitaret in nobis (Joan. I, 14): carnem assumpsit, non Verbum perdidit; quod non erat accepit, non quod erat amisit. Deus enim erat in Christo mundum reconcilians sibi (II Cor. V, 19). Quid ergo simile ego et Christus? Ad tollendas igitur omnes excusationes infidelis infirmitatis, martyres nobis stratam construxerunt. Lapideis enim tabulis construenda erat, qua securi ambularemus. Ipsi fecerunt sanguine suo, confessionibus suis. Denique contemptis corporibus suis, venienti ad gentes lucrandas Christo, tanquam in jumento illo sedenti, corpora sua sicut vestimenta straverunt (Matth. XXI, 7, 8). Quis est, quem pudeat dicere, Impar sum Deo? Plane impar. Impar sum Christo? Etiam mortali Christo impar. Petrus hoc erat quod tu, Paulus hoc erat quod tu, Apostoli et Prophetae hoc erant quod tu. Si piget imitari Dominum, imitare conservum. Praecessit agmen servorum, sublata est excusatio pigrorum. Postremo adhuc dicit: Impar sum Petro, impar sum Paulo. Impar es veritati? Coronatur rusticitas, non excusatur vanitas. Postremo impar es pueris? impar es puellis? impar es sanctae Valerianae? Si adhuc sequi piget, non vis adhaerere Victoriae? Sic enim nobis sanctorum viginti Martyrum series recitata est. Coepit ab episcopo Fidentio, clausit ad fidelem feminam sanctam Victoriam. Initium a fide, finis ad victoriam.
indeed God is set before us as One to be imitated, human frailty answers that it is a great thing for it to imitate Him to Whom it cannot be compared. If next the example of our Lord Jesus Christ Himself is set before us for imitation, Who for this reason, though He was God, was clothed in mortal flesh, that He might commend a precept to men bearing mortal flesh and show them an example; of Whom also it is written, Christ suffered for us, leaving us an example, that we should follow His footsteps (1 Pet. 2:21): yet here too human frailty still answers, What likeness is there between me and Christ? He, though flesh, is nevertheless the Word made flesh. For the Word was made flesh, that He might dwell in us (John 1:14): He took on flesh, He did not lose the Word; He received what He was not, He did not lose what He was. For God was in Christ reconciling the world to Himself (2 Cor. 5:19). What likeness then is there between me and Christ? To remove, therefore, all the excuses of faithless weakness, the martyrs have built us a paved road. For it had to be built of slabs of stone, on which we might walk secure. They made it with their blood, with their confessions. Finally, despising their own bodies, they spread their bodies like garments before Christ as He came to win the nations, sitting as it were upon that beast of burden (Matt. 21:7–8). Who is there who would be ashamed to say, I am unequal to God? Plainly unequal. I am unequal to Christ? Even to the mortal Christ unequal. Peter was what you are, Paul was what you are, the apostles and prophets were what you are. If it irks you to imitate the Lord, imitate your fellow servant. The column of servants has gone before; the excuse of the lazy has been taken away. Lastly he still says: I am unequal to Peter, I am unequal to Paul. Are you unequal to the truth? Rusticity is crowned, vanity is not excused. Lastly, are you unequal to boys? unequal to girls? unequal to Saint Valeriana? If it still irks you to follow, will you not cling to Victoria? For thus the series of the twenty holy martyrs was read out to us. It began with Bishop Fidentius, it closed with a faithful woman, Saint Victoria. The beginning from faith, the end at victory.
2. In martyribus non poena attenditur, sed causa. Donatistarum falsos martyres carpit. Videte ergo, fratres: sic celebrate passiones martyrum, ut cogitetis imitari martyres. Illi ut fructuosam haberent poenam, elegerunt causam. Attenderunt enim Dominum dicentem, non Beati qui persecutionem patiuntur; sed, Beati qui persecutionem patiuntur propter justitiam (Matth. V, 10). Elige causam, et non cures poenam. Si autem non eligis causam, et hic et in futuro invenies poenam. Non te commoveant supplicia et poenae malefacientium, sacrilegorum, hostium pacis, et inimicorum veritatis. Non enim illi pro veritate moriuntur: sed ideo moriuntur, ne veritas annuntietur, ne veritas praedicetur, ne veritas teneatur, ne unitas ametur, ne charitas diligatur, ne aeternitas teneatur. O causa pessima! ideo poena infructuosa. Non attendis, qui te de poena jactas, tres cruces fuisse, quando Dominus passus est? Inter duos latrones passus est Dominus: poena non discernebat, sed causa discernebat.
2. In martyrs it is not the punishment that is regarded, but the cause. He censures the false martyrs of the Donatists. See then, brethren: so celebrate the passions of the martyrs that you think of imitating the martyrs. They, that they might have a fruitful punishment, chose the cause. For they heeded the Lord saying, not, Blessed are they who suffer persecution; but, Blessed are they who suffer persecution for the sake of justice (Matt. 5:10). Choose the cause, and do not care about the punishment. But if you do not choose the cause, both here and in the future you will find punishment. Let not the tortures and punishments of evildoers, of the sacrilegious, of the enemies of peace and the foes of truth move you. For they do not die for the truth: rather they die so that the truth may not be proclaimed, that the truth may not be preached, that the truth may not be held, that unity may not be loved, that charity may not be cherished, that eternity may not be held. O worst of causes! therefore a fruitless punishment. Do you not notice, you who boast of your punishment, that there were three crosses when the Lord suffered? Between two robbers the Lord suffered: the punishment did not distinguish, but the cause distinguished.
Editors' notes and page, col. 1448

Footnotes

(1) ‹anchor: Impar es veritati› · call in col 1448

Victorinus Ms. : Impar es postea veritati. Forte legendum, Impar es rusticitati?

The Victorinus manuscript: "Are you then unequal to the truth?" Perhaps read: "Are you unequal to rusticity?"

(printed under page 730)

Page

  • running head: UGUSTINI EPISCOPI 1448 (start of head cut off at image edge)
  • marginal letters: (none)
  • old-edition numerals: (none)