causam. Multa mala patiuntur adulteri, multa mala patiuntur malefici, multa mala patiuntur latrones et homicidae, multa mala patiuntur scelerati omnes, multa mala, inquit, et ego martyr tuus patior: sed discerne causam meam de gente non sancta, latronum, homicidarum, scelestorum omnium. Pati talia, qualia ego, possunt: habere talem causam non possunt. Ego in fornace purgor; illi cinerescunt. Et haeretici patiuntur, et plura a se ipsis; et volunt martyres dici. Sed contra illos cantavimus, Discerne causam meam de gente non sancta. Non facit martyrem poena, sed causa.
cause. Adulterers suffer many evils, sorcerers suffer many evils, robbers and murderers suffer many evils, all the wicked suffer many evils; I too, he says, Thy martyr, suffer many evils: but distinguish my cause from the nation that is not holy, of robbers, of murderers, of all the wicked. They can suffer such things as I do: they cannot have such a cause. I am purified in the furnace; they turn to ashes. Heretics too suffer, and more at their own hands; and they wish to be called martyrs. But against them we have sung, Distinguish my cause from the nation that is not holy. It is not the penalty that makes a martyr, but the cause.
2. Crucifixorum cum Domino una poena fuit, sed dispar causa. In passione Domini tres cruces erant; una poena, sed dispar causa. Ad dexteram unus latro, ad sinistram alter latro: in medio judex, inter ambos pendens in cruce, quasi pronuntians de tribunali, audivit unum dicentem, Libera te, si justus es; audivit alterum parem suum corripientem et dicentem, Tu non times Deum? Nos pro malis nostris ista patimur; nam iste justus est. Malam habebat causam, et discernebat martyrum causam. Quid est enim aliud, Nos pro malis nostris ista patimur; nam iste justus est? Quis causam discerneret martyrum a causa impiorum poenam patientium? Iste, inquit, justus agnoscitur; nos pro nobis patimur, pro malis nostris patimur. Domine: vide quid dicat socio poenae suae. Christus pariter pendebat; sed non pariter vilescebat. Agnoscebatur Dominus a pendente. Unum erat crucis consortium; non erat unum praemium. Quid dico? Das Christo praemium, qui dator est praemiorum? Domine, inquit, memento mei, cum veneris in regnum tuum. Pendentem videbat, crucifixum videbat; et regnaturum sperabat. Memento, inquit, mei, non modo, sed cum veneris in regnum tuum. Multa, inquit, mala feci, requiem celerem non mihi spero: sufficiant tormenta mea usque ad adventum tuum. Modo torquear; cum veneris, tunc mihi parce. Ille se differebat; sed Christus paradisum non petenti offerebat. Memento mei: sed quando? Cum veneris in regnum tuum. Et Dominus: Amen dico tibi, hodie mecum eris in paradiso (Luc. XXIII, 39, 43). Discipuli mei dimiserunt me, discipuli mei desperaverunt de me; et tu in cruce cognovisti me, non contempsisti moriturum, sperasti regnaturum: Hodie mecum eris in paradiso. Non a te recedo. Discreta est causa; numquid poena? Bona ergo vox, Judica me, Deus, et discerne causam meam de gente non sancta. Omnes qui vivimus in hoc saeculo, laboremus ut bonam causam habeamus: ut si quid nobis acciderit in hoc saeculo, cum bona causa hinc exeamus.
2. Of those crucified with the Lord the penalty was one, but the cause unequal. In the Lord's passion there were three crosses; one penalty, but unequal cause. On the right one robber, on the left the other robber: in the middle the Judge, hanging on the cross between the two, as though pronouncing from the tribunal, heard one saying, Free Thyself, if Thou art just; He heard the other, his equal, rebuking him and saying, Do you not fear God? We suffer these things for our evil deeds; for this man is just. He had a bad cause, and he distinguished the cause of the martyrs. For what else is, We suffer these things for our evil deeds; for this man is just? Who would distinguish the cause of the martyrs from the cause of the impious suffering punishment? This man, he says, is recognized as just; we suffer for ourselves, we suffer for our evil deeds. Lord: see what he says to the companion of his punishment. Christ was hanging alike; but He was not alike held cheap. The Lord was recognized by one hanging. The fellowship of the cross was one; the reward was not one. What am I saying? Do you give Christ a reward, Who is the giver of rewards? Lord, he says, remember me, when Thou comest into Thy kingdom. He saw Him hanging, he saw Him crucified; and he hoped that He would reign. Remember me, he says, not now, but when Thou comest into Thy kingdom. I have done many evils, he says, I do not hope for speedy rest for myself: let my torments suffice until Thy coming. Let me be tortured now; when Thou comest, then spare me. He was putting himself off; but Christ was offering paradise to one who did not ask for it. Remember me: but when? When Thou comest into Thy kingdom. And the Lord: Amen I say to you, today you will be with Me in paradise (Luke 23:39, 43). My disciples have abandoned Me, My disciples have despaired of Me; and you on the cross have recognized Me, you have not despised Me as one about to die, you have hoped in Me as one about to reign: Today you will be with Me in paradise. I do not withdraw from you. The cause is distinguished; is the penalty? Good therefore is the cry, Judge me, O God, and distinguish my cause from the nation that is not holy. All of us who live in this world, let us labour to have a good cause: so that if anything befalls us in this world, we may depart hence with a good cause.