PL 39 · cols. 1713–1717
Augustine, Sermones 388-395 (Classis V, Sermones dubii)
Sermons CCCXCIII–CCCXCV
Migne Reading Room
PL 39 · cols. 1713–1717
Sermons CCCXCIII–CCCXCV
(*) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon title)› · call in col 1713 * Collatus ad tres cl. ad cr. cb. f. gr. r. rm. s. et ad Am. Er. Par. Lov.
Collated with three manuscripts cl., with cr., cb., f., gr., r., rm., s., and with the Amerbach, Erasmus, Paris and Louvain editions.
(printed under page 119)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon title)› · call in col 1713
(printed under page 119) (a) Alias, 41 inter Homilias 50.
Elsewhere, no. 41 among the Fifty Homilies.
(printed under page 119)
(b) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon title)› · call in col 1713
(printed under page 119) (b) Dubius erat Lovaniensibus, Verlino autem et Vindingo falsus aut centonis in modum ex variis laciniis conflatus videbatur. Exstat etiam inter opuscula Ambrosii ac Cæsarii, sed cum insigni varietate. Apud Ambrosium et Cæsarium prætermissis prioribus viginti quinque versibus, incipit in hæc verba : « Admoneo vos, fratres, in conspectu Dei, « timori vestro adjungere timorem meum, etc. Audite ergo « quæ dicturus sum. Certus sum, » etc. Sic in veteri quoque libro Ecclesiæ Carnutensis, in quo tamen Augustini nomen præfert.
It was doubtful to the Louvain editors, while to Verlinus and Vindingus it seemed false, or patched together like a cento from various scraps. It is also found among the minor works of Ambrose and of Caesarius, but with notable variation. In Ambrose and Caesarius the first twenty-five lines are passed over, and it begins with these words: "I warn you, brethren, in the sight of God, to join my fear to your fear, etc. Hear then what I am about to say. I am certain," etc. So too in an old book of the Church of Chartres, in which, however, it bears Augustine's name.
(printed under page 119) (a) Quæ paulo post cernuntur intra parenthesim, ipsa in Ambrosii ac Cæsarii editis et in Carnutensi Ms. sunt hic inserta, atque cum superioribus ita colligata : « et recon« ciliatus, si postea bene vixerit, securus est. Sed dicis : « Quid est, bene vixerit ? Vel hoc nos instrue, bone sacer« dos : tu nescire, » etc. Postque verba in parenthesis fine, « et post pœnitentiam melius ; » subjungitur, « Agens « vero pœnitentiam ad ultimum et reconciliatus, » etc. Cæterum quidquid est parenthesi contentum, abest prorsus a manuscriptis libris Homiliarum 50.
What is seen a little below within the parenthesis is inserted here in the editions of Ambrose and Caesarius and in the Chartres manuscript, and joined to what precedes thus: "and reconciled, if afterwards he lives well, he is safe. But you say: What is it, to live well? Instruct us in this at least, good priest: you say you do not know," etc. And after the words at the end of the parenthesis, "and after penance better," there follows, "But one who does penance at the last and is reconciled," etc. However, all that the parenthesis contains is entirely absent from the manuscript books of the Fifty Homilies.
(printed under page 119)
(1) ‹anchor: tamen gravia› · call in col 1714
¹ Apud Ambrosium : Ecce quam levia dixi, ut tacerem gravia. In cr. libro, et omisi illa gravia. In reliquis liber iste cr. Ambrosianis editis fere consentit.
In Ambrose: "See how light the things I have said, so as to keep silent about the grave ones." In manuscript cr., "and I have left out those grave ones." In the rest this manuscript cr. mostly agrees with the Ambrosian editions.
(printed under page 119)
(a) ‹anchor: et reconciliatus› · call in col 1714
(printed under page 119)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon title)› · call in col 1715
(printed under page 120) (a) Ex Vaticana bibliotheca erutus per Holstensium.
Brought to light from the Vatican Library by Holstenius.
(printed under page 120) (a) Nunc primum prodit erutus ex vetustissimo codies Remigiano.
Now published for the first time, brought to light from a very old codex of Saint-Remi. [Print reads "codies", apparently for "codice".]
(printed under page 120)
(1) ‹anchor: et in persecutoribus› · call in col 1716
¹ Forte, tu in terra, et me persequeris.
Perhaps "tu in terra, et me persequeris" (you on earth, and you persecute me).
(printed under page 120)
(a) ‹anchor: not visible (sermon title)› · call in col 1716
(printed under page 120)