PL 4 · cols. 240–244
Cyprianus, Epistolae II-XXI
Letter VII
Migne Reading Room
PL 4 · cols. 240–244
Letter VII
LECTIONES VARIANTES. (printed under page 116)
(a) ‹ut› · call in col 241
Religionem vestram, ut Rig.
"Your religion," as in Rig.
(printed under page 116)
(b) ‹non paruerit› · call in col 241
Fecerit M. R.
"Fecerit" ("has done") M. R.
(printed under page 116)
(c) ‹tumida› · call in col 241
Tumor Corb.
"Tumor" ("swelling") Corb.
(printed under page 116)
(d) ‹et tormenta› · call in col 241
In tormenta venerunt, tormenta Corb.
"They came into torments, torments" Corb.
(printed under page 116)
(e) ‹profecerit› · call in col 241
Defecerit Oxon.
"Defecerit" ("has failed") Oxon.
(printed under page 116)
(f) ‹in judiciis meis› · call in col 241
Viis meis Voss. 1. Pem.
"In my ways" Voss. 1, Pem.
(printed under page 116)
(g) ‹dignatus est› · call in col 242
Dignatur Oxon.
"Dignatur" ("deigns") Oxon.
(printed under page 116)
(h) ‹Petite, et impetratis› · call in col 242
Impetrabilis Bod. 3. Vet. innom.
"Impetrabilis" ("able to obtain") Bod. 3, an unnamed old [edition].
(printed under page 116)
(i) ‹dispares› · call in col 242
Dissonantes voces et dissipatas Lin.
"Discordant and scattered voices" Lin.
(printed under page 116)
(j) ‹convenerit› · call in col 242
Duo ex vobis convenerint Bod. 1, 3. Voss. 1, 2. conveneritis Rig.
"Two of you agree" (plural verb) Bod. 1, 3, Voss. 1, 2; "conveneritis" ("you agree") Rig.
(printed under page 116)
(k) ‹oriretur› · call in col 242
Operaretur Lin. Et videmus Vet. innom.
"Operaretur" ("was at work") Lin.; "And we see" an unnamed old [edition].
STEPH. BALUZII NOTAE. (Baluze) ‹Epist. VII.— De precando Deo› · lemma note
(continued) Illa etiam omiserunt Angli. Nos restituimus propter auctoritatem Augustini et plurimorum veterum librorum.
(Baluze) ‹I.— Religiosam sollicitudinem› · lemma note I. — Religiosam sollicitudinem. Haec est lectio omnium veterum librorum et editionum. In Rigaltiana tamen scriptum est religionem vestram. Angli reposuerunt veterem lectionem.
I. — "Religiosam sollicitudinem" (devout solicitude). This is the reading of all the old books and editions. In Rigault's, however, "religionem vestram" (your religion) is written. The English restored the old reading.
(Baluze) ‹Viam Domini non tenemus› · lemma note Viam Domini non tenemus. Citat hunc quoque locum sanctus Augustinus in libro paulo ante laudato, cap. 3.
"Viam Domini non tenemus" (we do not keep the way of the Lord). Saint Augustine also cites this passage in the book praised a little above, chapter 3.
(Baluze) ‹IV.— Oriretur› · lemma note IV. — Oriretur. In uno codice regio legitur, vastitatis hujus accederet et impetus malitiae nostrae erga nos ingrueret. Sed alii codices repugnant et omnes editiones. In vetustissimo codice Remigiano scriptum est, tempestas vastationis hujus oriretur. In Lamoniano, tempestas vastis hujus operaretur.
IV. — "Oriretur" (should arise). In one royal manuscript one reads "of this devastation should come on and the onset of our malice should fall upon us." But the other manuscripts and all the editions are against it. In the very old Saint-Remi manuscript is written "the storm of this laying waste should arise." In the Lamoignon one, "the storm of this waste should be at work."
(printed under page 116)
LECTIONES VARIANTES. (printed under page 117)
(a) ‹non olim› · call in col 243
Jam olim Erasm.
"Long since" Erasm.
(printed under page 117)
(b) ‹aliena peccata› · call in col 243
Nostra peccata Lin. Voss. 1, 2. Bod. 1. Pem.
"Our sins" Lin., Voss. 1, 2, Bod. 1, Pem.
(printed under page 117)
(c) ‹Nec ipsi denique› · call in col 244
Ipsi utique Oxon.
"Ipsi utique" ("you yourselves certainly") Oxon.
STEPH. BALUZII NOTAE. (Baluze) ‹V.— Pectoris nostri› · lemma note V. — Pectoris nostri. Duae sunt hujus loci lectiones in antiquis codicibus. Eam quam nos retinemus invenimus in octo codicibus. Aliam, quae habet peccati nostri, exhibent omnes editiones quae Pamelianam antecesserunt, eam vero praeferunt etiam undecim libri veteres ; eaque adjuvari potest ex eo quod in initio libri Job reperitur : ut quaeras iniquitatem meam et peccatum meum scruteris. Nostram vero confirmant plurima sacrae Scripturae loca in quibus Deus vocatur scrutator cordis et renis, ut etiam adnotatur in calce Epistolae octavae. In codice Flori scriptum erat peccati nostri.
V. — "Pectoris nostri" (of our breast). There are two readings of this passage in the ancient manuscripts. The one we keep we found in eight manuscripts. The other, which has "peccati nostri" (of our sin), all the editions before Pamelius's give, and eleven old books also show it; and it can be supported by what is found at the beginning of the book of Job: "that you seek out my iniquity and search out my sin." Ours, however, is confirmed by very many places of Holy Scripture in which God is called the searcher of heart and reins, as is also noted at the end of the eighth letter. In the manuscript of Florus "peccati nostri" was written.
(Baluze) ‹VII.— Nec ipsi denique› · lemma note VII. — Nec ipsi denique. Quamquam prior lectio, quae habet utique, bona sit, eam praetuli quae nititur auctoritate omnium fere veterum exemplarium.
VII. — "Nec ipsi denique" (nor in short should you yourselves). Although the earlier reading, which has "utique," is good, I have preferred the one that rests on the authority of almost all the old copies.
(Baluze) ‹Intercipere› · lemma note Intercipere, id est supprimere, modo loquendi multum remoto a vera significatione hujus vocabuli. Et tamen Tacitus in Vita Agricolae videtur eo vocabulo usus esse in eodem sensu quo Cyprianus. Ait enim : Nec Agricola unquam per alios gesta avidus intercepit, sed centurio seu praefectus incorruptum facti testem habebat. Item Seneca, lib. de Beneficiis, p. 17 : Urit illum et angit intercepti beneficii conscientia. Q. Curtius lib. XV : Alieno enim sanguine partam gloriam intercipi. Arnobius lib. III : Nam intercipere scripta et publicatam velle submergere lectionem non est deos defendere, sed veritatis testificationem timere. Cassianus, l. IX, c. 11 : Intercipiens efficaciam orationum, et Collat. lib. I, cap. 11 : Charitas nullo intercipiatur tempore.
"Intercipere" (to intercept), that is, to suppress, a way of speaking far removed from the true meaning of this word. Yet Tacitus in the Life of Agricola seems to have used the word in the same sense as Cyprian. For he says: "Nor did Agricola ever greedily appropriate what others had done; but centurion or prefect had in him an honest witness of the deed." Likewise Seneca, book On Benefits, p. 17: "The consciousness of a benefit suppressed burns and torments him." Quintus Curtius book 15: "[that] glory won by another's blood be intercepted." Arnobius book 3: "For to suppress writings and to wish to drown a published reading is not to defend the gods, but to fear the testimony of truth." Cassian, book 9, chapter 11: "intercepting the efficacy of prayers," and Conferences book 1, chapter 11: "Let charity be intercepted at no time."
(Baluze) ‹Perdidit› · lemma note Perdidit. Ita veteres editiones et omnes fere libri veteres. In uno tamen meo scriptum est indicit. Quod videtur esse melius. In vetustissimo Remigiano percidit.
"Perdidit" (she lost). So the old editions and almost all the old books. In one of mine, however, is written "indicit." That seems better. In the very old Saint-Remi manuscript, "percidit."
(printed under page 117)