PL 54 · cols. 511–514
Sermones S. Leoni Magno attributi (Appendix ad primam partem operum S. Leonis Magni), I-XX
Sermons XVI–XVII
Migne Reading Room
PL 54 · cols. 511–514
Sermons XVI–XVII
(a) ‹anchor: subditis imperans. Ita› · call in col 511
Luxatus valde hic locus est.
This passage is badly out of joint.
(printed under page 261)
(b) ‹anchor: de tumulo surgens› · call in col 511
Forte, recta, vel aliquid supplendum, ex gr., volatu.
Perhaps recta, or something is to be supplied, for example volatu.
(printed under page 261)
Licet hic sermo spectet ad appendicem collect. 2, cujus sermones ascititios ostendimus in praefatione Sermonibus praemissa num. 19, unde etiam in ms. Casanatensi ejusdem collectionis omissi fuere, cum tamen ex ms., ut videtur, basilicae S. Petri, veluti Leonis allegetur ex testimonio Petri Mallii, quod in eadem praefatione eodemque numero recitavimus, hinc ne quis forte de sermone genuino suspicaretur, qui a nobis inventus non fuerit, eum appendici inserendum putavimus. Auctor aliquis Romanus pontifex videtur.
Although this sermon belongs to the appendix of collection 2, whose sermons we have shown, in the preface prefixed to the Sermons, no. 19, to be adventitious, whence they were also omitted in the Casanatense manuscript of the same collection, yet since it is cited as Leo's, from a manuscript, as it seems, of the basilica of St Peter, on the testimony of Petrus Mallius, which we recited in the same preface and under the same number, for this reason, lest anyone should perhaps suspect a genuine sermon that had not been found by us, we have thought that it ought to be inserted in the appendix. The author seems to be some Roman pontiff.
<!-- note: a single italic admonition (hanging indent, ten lines) in the lower middle of the column, directly under the title SERMO XVI. and its rubric In Natali SS. apostolorum Petri et Pauli., and directly above CAP. I. (Duorum sanctorum apostolorum Petri et Pauli). Above the title stands the end of Sermo XV, run over from col. 510. The admonition does not run over from or into a neighbouring column; the foot of the column holds footnote matter, set elsewhere. The "other" line of the notes of 511, which is said to quote this admonition with its English beside the misprint remarks, lies in a file not named for this pass and was NOT edited; the quotation still has to be taken out of it there. English made fresh from the page. -->
(c) ‹anchor: SERMO XVII.› · call in col 512
Ita ex cod. Vallicel. et duobus Vat. Al., De S. Paulo, seu, De Festivitate S. Pauli.
So from the Vallicellian codex and two Vatican ones. Others, De S. Paulo, or De Festivitate S. Pauli.
(printed under page 261)
Ex cod. collect. 2 nuper editus est ab abb. Trombellio. Praeter mss. coll. 2 eum invenimus in cod. Casin. coll. 1, nec non in duobus Lectionariis Vallicell. VII, et A, 6, ubique Leonis papae nomen praeferentem. In duobus autem Vat. 1272 et 3835, sine certo ullius auctoris nomine haec inscriptio legitur: Item ejusdem in Natali B. Pauli apostoli; quae eumdem hujus et praecedentis sermonis auctorem significare solet: praecedit autem in utroque cod. sermo S. Joanni Chrysostomo inscriptus. Cum vero hujus sermonis auctor sit certe Romanus, hic manifesta detegitur alicujus librarii oscitantia ejus generis, cujus in praefatione meminimus num. 9, ut scilicet hunc sermonem descripserit cum eadem epigraphe ex antiquiori Lectionario, tametsi praecedentem sermonem, cui veri auctoris nomen in eodem erat praefixum, nequaquam excerpserit. Auctor autem Romanus magno Gregorio posterior est: siquidem hujus temporibus, Micrologo teste de Ecclesiast. Observat. cap. 42, S. Pauli festivitas altera die post festum SS. Petri et Pauli celebrari coepit. In sacramentariis quidem Gregoriano antiquioribus, nimirum Leoniano
It was lately published from a codex of collection 2 by the abbot Trombelli. Besides the manuscripts of collection 2 we have found it in a Cassinese codex of collection 1, and also in two Vallicellian Lectionaries, VII and A, 6, everywhere bearing the name of Pope Leo. But in two Vatican codices, 1272 and 3835, without the sure name of any author, this inscription is read: Likewise of the same, on the Birthday of the blessed apostle Paul; which usually signifies the same author for this and for the preceding sermon: but in both codices there goes before it a sermon inscribed to St John Chrysostom. Since, however, the author of this sermon is certainly a Roman, there is here laid bare the manifest drowsiness of some copyist, of the kind we mentioned in the preface, no. 9: namely, that he copied this sermon with the same heading from an older Lectionary, although he by no means excerpted the preceding sermon, to which the true author's name was prefixed in it. The Roman author, moreover, is later than Gregory the Great: since it was in his times, on the witness of the Micrologus, On Ecclesiastical Observances, ch. 42, that the feast of St Paul began to be celebrated on the day after the feast of Saints Peter and Paul. In the sacramentaries older than the Gregorian, indeed, namely the Leonine
(a) ‹anchor: memoria celebratur,› · call in col 513
Cod. Vat. 3835, nimis fidelium mentes gaudio relevantur.
The Vatican codex 3835: nimis fidelium mentes gaudio relevantur.
(printed under page 262)
(b) ‹anchor: charissimi, huic› · call in col 513
Al., sacratissimae.
Others, sacratissimae.
(printed under page 262)
(c) ‹anchor: desidia irretire› · call in col 513
A., torporis.
Others [printed "A." for "Al."], torporis.
(printed under page 262)
(d) ‹anchor: cives excusationis› · call in col 513
Sic Vat. cod. Al., proferent in eo : et post nonnulla, defensionis tueri noscuntur ope.
So the Vatican codex. Others, proferent in eo; and a little further on, defensionis tueri noscuntur ope.
(printed under page 262)
(e) ‹anchor: Hesterno quippe› · call in col 513
In quibusdam codd. deest die ; male.
In some codices die is missing; wrongly.
(printed under page 262)
(f) ‹anchor: martyrio sunt› · call in col 513
Al., consecrati.
Others, consecrati.
(printed under page 262)
(g) ‹anchor: in alium diem› · call in col 513
Ms. Barb. : B. apostoli Pauli ratio erat transferenda. Cod. Casanat. : B. apostoli Pauli inerat ratio transferendae Vallicell. cod. : B. apostoli Pauli celebritatis erat ratio transferendae. Secuti sumus cod. Vat
The Barberini manuscript: B. apostoli Pauli ratio erat transferenda. The Casanatense codex: B. apostoli Pauli inerat ratio transferendae. The Vallicellian codex: B. apostoli Pauli celebritatis erat ratio transferendae. We have followed the Vatican codex.
(printed under page 262)
(h) ‹anchor: ita in ejus› · call in col 513
Al., apostoli.
Others, apostoli.
(printed under page 262)
(i) ‹anchor: plures aut› · call in col 513
Al., desideriis.
Others, desideriis.
(printed under page 262)
(j) ‹anchor: mundanae cogitationis› · call in col 513
Vocem cura, quae in aliis codicibus desideratur, suggessit optimus cod. Vat., ex quo mox desideria scripsimus, pro desidia, ut alia exemplaria praeferunt.
The word cura, which is wanting in the other codices, was supplied by the excellent Vatican codex, from which we have just afterwards written desideria in place of desidia, as the other copies give.
(printed under page 262)
(k) ‹anchor: pares eos› · call in col 513
Id est, apostolatus honore.
That is, by the honour of the apostolate.
(printed under page 262)
(l) ‹anchor: dignatio, ita› · call in col 513
Al., similiter. Cod. Vat., coaequales.
Others, similiter. The Vatican codex, coaequales.
(printed under page 262)
uti vocant, et Gelasiano, utriusque apostoli natale eadem die designatur, nec sequenti die describitur alia missa S. Pauli propria, ut in Gregoriano primum deprehenditur. Hunc sermonem in plerisque mss. exemplaribus mutilum, in solo antiquissimo Vat. 3835 integrum invenire potuimus.
[... the Leonine,] as they call it, and in the Gelasian, the natal day of both apostles is marked on the same day, nor is another Mass, proper to St Paul, set down for the following day, as is first found in the Gregorian. This sermon, mutilated in most manuscript copies, we have been able to find entire only in the very ancient Vat. 3835.
<!-- note: the end of the Ballerini's italic admonition to Sermo XVII, six lines at the very head of the column, continued from col. 512 and set here from "uti vocant" only. The column's first printed letters are "nino," the tail of the word Leonino, split across the column break and already set whole in the notes of 512, so not repeated here (the tail reads "nino" on the page, confirmed in the Q8a re-read, and col. 512 ends "Leo-"; if the notes of 512 set the word as Leoniano, it is to be corrected there to Leonino). "[... the Leonine,]" in the English is supplied to carry the sentence over from col. 512 and should be matched to the English set there. The admonition ends in this column at "invenire potuimus." and is followed directly by CAP. I. (Gemina hodiernae festivitatis) of the sermon, then caps II and III, and footnote matter at the foot, set elsewhere. The "other" line of the notes of 513, which is said to quote this passage with its English, lies in a file not named for this pass and was NOT edited; the quotation still has to be taken out of it there. English made fresh from the page. -->
(m) ‹anchor: misericordia! Modicum› · call in col 514
Sic idem Vat. Alias male, enim.
So the same Vatican codex. Elsewhere, wrongly, enim.
(printed under page 262)
(n) ‹anchor: multipliciter consolaretur.› · call in col 514
Sequentia in solo antiquissimo Vat. codice leguntur ; ubi mox, pro superflue, legendum videtur superne.
What follows is read only in the very ancient Vatican codex; where just afterwards, for superflue, it seems superne should be read.
(printed under page 262)