CAPUT IV. — 4. Zachariae et Mariae eadem fere verba, non eadem incredulitas. Verum interest plurimum, non solum in matribus, quod illa virgo, illa mulier fuerit sterilis; illa de Spiritu sancto pariens Filium Dei Dominum nostrum, illa de viro suo sene pariens praecursorem Domini. Et illud attendite. Non credidit Zacharias. Quomodo non credidit? Quaesivit ab angelo per quid cognosceret quod promittebat, quoniam ipse erat senex, et uxor ejus processerat in diebus suis. Et dixit illi angelus: Ecce eris tacens, et non poteris loqui usque in diem quo haec fiant, propter quod non credidisti verbis meis, quae implebuntur in tempore suo. Idem ipse angelus venit ad Mariam, nuntiat Christum nasciturum ex ea in carne, et Maria tale aliquid dicit. Ille enim dixit: Per quid cognoscam hoc? Ego enim sum senex, et uxor mea processit in diebus suis. Et dicitur ei: Ecce eris tacens: et non poteris loqui usque in diem quo haec implebuntur, propter quod non credidisti verbis meis. Et accepit supplicium taciturnitatis, merito infidelitatis. Quid dixerat propheta de Joanne? Vox clamantis in eremo (Isai. XL, 3). Tacet Zacharias generaturus vocem. Quia non credidit, tacuit: merito obmutuit quousque vox nasceretur. Si enim recte dictum est, imo quia valde recte dictum est in sancto psalmo, Credidi, propter quod locutus sum (Psal. CXV, 10): quia non credebat, merito non loquebatur. Sed rogo, Domine, cum audientibus me pariter pulso, aperi nobis, expone nobis quid sibi velit haec quaestio. Causas quaerit Zacharias ab angelo, per quid cognosceret quod illi annuntiatum est, quoniam senex erat, et uxor ejus progressa in diebus suis: dicitur ei, Quoniam non credidisti, eris tacens. Nuntiatur Christus virgini Mariae, et ipsa causam quaerit, et dicit angelo, Quomodo fiet istud? quoniam virum non cognosco. Et ille, Per quid cognoscam hoc? Ego enim sum senex, et uxor mea progressa in diebus suis. Et illa, Quomodo fiet istud? Quoniam virum non cognosco. Illi dicitur, Tacebis, quia non credis: illi autem causa exponitur, silentium non imponitur. Quomodo fiet istud? Quoniam virum non cognosco. Et angelus: Spiritus sanctus superveniet in te, et virtus Altissimi obumbrabit tibi. Ecce quomodo fiet quod quaeris, ecce quomodo virum non cognoscis et paries, ecce quomodo: quia Spiritus sanctus superveniet in te, et virtus Altissimi obumbrabit tibi. Non timeas aestum libidinis, sub tantae umbraculo sanctitatis. Quare hoc? Si verba attendamus, aut ambo crediderunt, aut ambo dubitaverunt, Zacharias et Maria. Sed nos verba valemus audire: Deus potest et corda interrogare.
Chapter IV. — 4. Zechariah and Mary spoke almost the same words, but did not share the same unbelief. Yet there is a very great difference, not only in the mothers, in that the one was a virgin, the other a barren woman; the one bearing by the Holy Spirit the Son of God, our Lord, the other bearing by her aged husband the forerunner of the Lord. Attend to this as well. Zechariah did not believe. How did he not believe? He asked the angel by what he might know what he was promising, since he himself was old, and his wife was advanced in her days. And the angel said to him: Behold, you will be silent, and you will not be able to speak until the day on which these things come to pass, because you did not believe my words, which will be fulfilled in their time. The very same angel comes to Mary, announces that Christ will be born of her in the flesh, and Mary says something of the same kind. For he said: By what shall I know this? For I am old, and my wife has advanced in her days. And it is said to him: Behold, you will be silent, and you will not be able to speak until the day on which these things are fulfilled, because you did not believe my words. And he received the punishment of silence, as the desert of unbelief. What had the prophet said of John? The voice of one crying in the desert (Isa. 40:3). Zechariah is silent who is to beget the voice. Because he did not believe, he was silent: deservedly he was struck dumb until the voice should be born. For if it was rightly said, nay since it was very rightly said in the holy psalm, I believed, because of which I have spoken (Ps. 115:10): since he did not believe, deservedly he did not speak. But I ask, Lord, together with those who hear me I knock: open to us, explain to us what this question means. Zechariah asks the angel for reasons, by what he might know what had been announced to him, since he was old, and his wife advanced in her days: it is said to him, Because you did not believe, you will be silent. Christ is announced to the virgin Mary, and she too asks for a reason, and says to the angel, How shall this come about, since I do not know a man? And he: By what shall I know this? For I am old, and my wife advanced in her days. And she: How shall this come about? Since I do not know a man. To him it is said, You will be silent, because you do not believe: to her, however, the reason is explained, silence is not imposed. How shall this come about? Since I do not know a man. And the angel: The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you. Behold how what you ask shall come about, behold how you do not know a man and yet will give birth, behold how: because the Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you. Do not fear the heat of lust under the shade of such great holiness. Why is this? If we attend to the words, either both believed or both doubted, Zechariah and Mary. But we are able to hear words: God is able to question hearts as well.
CAPUT V. — 5. Zacharias desperando interrogat, Maria inquirendo. Gratia Dei quam maxima in incarnatione Verbi. Intelligimus, charissimi, quoniam Zacharias quando ait, Per quid cognoscam hoc? ego enim sum senex, et uxor mea progressa in diebus suis, desperando dixit, non inquirendo: Maria vero quando e contra ait, Quomodo fiet istud? quoniam virum non
Chapter V. — 5. Zechariah asks in despair, Mary in inquiry. The very great grace of God in the incarnation of the Word. We understand, dearly beloved, that Zechariah, when he says, By what shall I know this? for I am old, and my wife advanced in her days, spoke in despair, not in inquiry: but Mary, when on the contrary she says, How shall this come about, since I do not